The Money Culture War

Yesterday’s New York Times carried a column worth reading by David Brooks. It is a little confused, even by the standards of Times columns, but the gist of it is a call to arms for a brand new culture war, this one over money.

I’m all for that.

Brooks starts out by recalling a centuries old idea.

The theory was that great nations start out tough-minded and energetic. Toughness and energy lead to wealth and power. Wealth and power lead to affluence and luxury. Affluence and luxury lead to decadence, corruption and decline.

This was a theory invented for, and more or less exclusively applied to, the fall of the Roman Empire. But don’t let the fact that it’s long since been cast aside by historians distract you. Brooks thinks we’ve gone soft.

In the good old days (pre-1980, apparently) we Americans kept ourselves tough and energetic no matter how rich we got. No luxury or decadence here. Nope. Not the American way. We’re strong.

That’s because despite the country’s notorious materialism, there has always been a countervailing stream of sound economic values. The early settlers believed in Calvinist restraint. The pioneers volunteered for brutal hardship during their treks out west. Waves of immigrant parents worked hard and practiced self-denial so their children could succeed.

Yeah, okay. But let’s call a spade a spade here. The reason we didn’t let our riches become complaisant luxury is because no matter how rich we got, we wanted to get richer. Those are our sound economic values. Calvinist restraint was not motivated by the shame of public ostentation, it was motivated by a belief that you should save and invest to become as wealthy as possible, because divine favor was manifest in material success.

And here is where Brooks gets really confused, telling us that our moral decline began when we started legalizing gambling and when "executives and hedge fund managers began bragging about compensation packages."

I know many executives and hedge fund managers and I’ve never heard one brag about their compensation package. Of course, all of them have an earnest desire for even larger wheelbarrows full of money. But how is that not in keeping with our traditional Calvinist culture?

Brooks’ contribution is to call for a new culture war to get the nation back on track economically. You are familiar with the old culture war, aren’t you? That’s the fight between those that want to destroy evolution and those that want to destroy Christmas. It’s hugely important to hundreds of people.

As I said, I’m all in favor of a new protracted fight over our money culture for the hearts and minds of op-ed contributors everywhere. I might even get a book deal out of it.

But it seems to me that our core culture is unchanged and unthreatened. Supersized restaurant portions aside, we haven’t gone soft. We still want to get richer and are prepared to work hard and go without to do so. We just can’t figure out how to do it anymore. Our economy has grown and evolved to the point where our basic instincts to accumulate more are not enough. There is no 21st Century equivalent of "Go west young man." For most Americans, the problem is not a lack of drive to get richer, it’s a lack of knowledge. And, as I probably don’t need to add, mainstream personal finance advice is not helping much.

So let the war commence! I’m not sure what the sides are exactly, although I think that whatever they are Brooks and I are not on the same one. Still, this does sound like fun.

Media, The Big Picture | Frank Curmudgeon | September 30, 2009 11:59 am

13 Comments

By Jim, September 30, 2009 @ 2:54 pm

Sounds good to me. I think a culture war over money would be more compelling TV than the current war over Xmas vs Darwin.
By Hantu, September 30, 2009 @ 5:59 pm

I like the whole “war on concept” stuff… War on Christmas, drugs, terror…

I can’t wait for someone to declare war on the wind or sunshine…

Palin 2012 anyone?
By Matt, September 30, 2009 @ 7:30 pm

I agree that many of us still want to get richer and are willing to work hard and sacrifice, yet we can’t figure out how to do it anymore as the evolution of the economy has overwhelmed.

I disagree that the problem is lack of knowledge. Honestly, the more I know, the less I trust most of the basics: Social Security, Medicare, the US dollar, Treasuries, buy-and-hold index funds, the affordability of a basic house, the value of a Bachelor’s degree.

If you were earning 42k per year (gross), wtf would you really do?
By Adam, September 30, 2009 @ 10:51 pm

“It’s hugely important to hundreds of people.”

Great line
By Rick Francis, October 1, 2009 @ 10:16 am

>There is no 21st Century equivalent of “Go west young man.”

How about “Go online young man”? I find it hard to believe there is no more big opportunities online, the internet hasn’t been mainstream 20 years yet.

-Rick

-Rick Francis
By Rob Bennett, October 1, 2009 @ 12:55 pm

Our economy has grown and evolved to the point where our basic instincts to accumulate more are not enough. There is no 21st Century equivalent of “Go west young man.” For most Americans, the problem is not a lack of drive to get richer, it’s a lack of knowledge.

My take is 100 percent opposite of Frank’s take. I think that what Brooks is saying is important.

I think “Go West, Young Man!” applies 10 times more today than it ever has before. The opportunities sitting before us on a plate are just amazing. And, no, I don’t see any intellectual deficiency that stops us from reaping the benefits.

The core problem is indeed cultural. You have to want to get rich to pull it off. Too many of us today are too complacent to do what it takes or even to cheer on those who try.

I think that one problem is that material luxuries are no longer special. We need to be striving for a new kind of luxury, greater work satisfaction and greater cultural satisfaction and greater spiritual satisfaction. These things are often mocked and ignored today. But to motivate large numbers of people to do what it would take to get us moving forward again, we need to look to new and stronger and more enduring motivators.

I like it that Brooks is not attacking left or right, Democrat or Republican. He is going to the root. I share his view that the root problem is not one that can be blamed on one party or one ideology. It’s bigger than that. That’s why many have a hard time grasping it, in my assessment.

Rob
By racy, October 1, 2009 @ 9:02 pm

I guess I’m not sure what the sides of the war are. Nevertheless, I would like to see more self relianace, more savings, less consumerism. Most young people I talk to don’t have any idea about the Magic of Compound Interest. One doesn’t need to work hard forever IF they would just get in the habit of saving & investing as early as possible. It’s easy to become a millionaire and better!
By Doups, May 17, 2023 @ 7:18 am

Source: Press Release The deal, including all new RAW game engines, SuperSlice and SuperTracks, as well as the existing slot catalogue through the RAW iGaming purchase of Leander Games. The unique RAW games will launch in June and will be made available on the ground breaking and innovative Battle of Slots concept that Videoslots has pioneered and perfected over the years. We’ve made some important changes to our Privacy and Cookies Policy and we want you to know what this means for you and your data. “This is a fantastic event and it is sure to establish itself as a must-attend conference in the diary for the online gaming community. Its Baltic and Scandinavian focus, with a careful selection of high-quality speakers on the panels, an amazing location, organizers’ dedication to creating a welcoming and friendly atmosphere, make it a one-of-a-kind event that proved to be really productive for us. We’re sure to return next year!”
https://www.arnlweb.com/forums/profile/dominic94v53690/
The PokerStars bonus code opens the door to a very generous welcome bonus offer for new online accounts. A PokerStars promo code can also be used in conjunction with any ongoing incentive offers. VIP Program: In addition to the 100% up to $600 bonus you’ll receive using the PokerStars Marketing Code, the site also offers a comprehensive VIP program which includes prizes, cash bonuses, increased points earning, tournament entries and much more. Below we’ve included a graphic that outlines exactly how many points you’ll need to reach to get to each level of the VIP program at PokerStars. Note that these levels are separate from the bonus offer and are an added benefit of playing at the site in real money games and real tournaments.
By Tar, May 23, 2023 @ 3:00 pm

One should know that every large or mid-cap company was once a small-cap company and the one who grows their business and sustains its profits can only graduate and step up the ladder from small to midcap or largecap company. Most of the small-cap companies have low revenues and small number of employees as compared to bigger companies. U.S. stock markets have been witnessing a steady northbound journey since mid-October. The rally in the U.S. stock markets is likely to sustain in the near term on expectations of a slowing inflation rate and a reduction in the magnitude of the interest rate hike by the Fed. At present, the Fed fund rate is within the range of 3.75-4%. We’ll be in your inbox every morning Monday-Saturday with all the day’s top business news, inspiring stories, best advice and exclusive reporting from Entrepreneur.
https://cbdwavelength.com/beginners-guide-to-cannabidiol-oil-why-everybody-needs-to-take-cbd/
Despite the encouraging fall in market supply, EVs remain the slowing-selling used power train type. Its 69 days of supply in the market compares with petrol (40 days), diesel (43 days) and hybrid (49 days). This suggests a further fall in prices could be needed to fuel demand, especially on the newer more expensive used EVs. Learn More Beyond providing a charging service, Volta specializes in generating advertising revenues from screens embedded into the charge point. NEW YORK–(BUSINESS WIRE)–Volta Inc. (“Volta”) today announced that Shell USA, Inc., a subsidiary of Shell plc, has completed the previously announced acquisition of Volta in an all-cash transaction…. The resignations of Chief Executive Officer Scott Mercer and President Chris Wendel came a week after the San Francisco-based firm postponed reporting its latest quarterly earnings, although it was unclear if there was any connection between the events. Mercer will continue in the CEO role for a transition period as the company’s board searches for a replacement.
By Paito, May 25, 2023 @ 3:57 pm

The best Ohio sports betting apps went live soon after the ball dropped on Jan. 1, 2023, giving Buckeye State bettors the opportunity to wager on the Bengals’ NFL playoffs run. Thirteen Ohio sports betting sites are now available: BetMGM, Caesars Sportsbook, FanDuel, DraftKings, Tipico, PointsBet, BetRivers, SuperBook, Betway, Betfred, Barstool, Hard Rock and Betr. There’s no other way to put it: The early days of legal Illinois sports betting featured a turbulent start. After Illinois lawmakers formally approved legal sports betting in 2019, physical sportsbooks began taking bets in early March just in time for the rush of March Madness that is the NCAA Tournament. That excitement was very short-lived as retail locations were shut down (along with sports leagues across the globe) in response to growing fears about COVID-19.
https://riverlkif962963.blogtov.com/17511451/money-lines-ncaa-basketball
The same goes for teams. If in real life we know Manchester United, Real Madrid, Barcelona, Bayern Munich, PSG, and Juventus, well, you already know the trick: on Zoom Soccer, we have Z.Manchester United, Z.Real Madrid, Z.Barcelona, Z.Bayern Munich, Z.PSG and Z.Juventus. Before speaking of predictions, if you want to start placing some bets on Zoom Soccer and making some predictions and comparing them, you have to go to the Bet9ja website first. If you don’t have an account already, you can quickly create one through the “Register” button at the top right corner of the page. If you already do have one, simply enter your credentials and log in. Afterward, click on the “Soccer Zoom” button to be redirected to the page dedicated to it. It was around June 2020 Bet9ja rolled out a new virtual game they called zoom, with its livescores available on their other website Zoomscores, it was indeed a perfect time to release such a software as at this time most countries including Nigeria was on lock-down due to the outbreak of the deadly Coronavirus (Covid-19), before the release of zoom other leading bookies such as Betking, Merrybet and Nairabet also introduced simulated reality games (SRL), this was a die hard attempt to save the face of sports betting as most sports event were shut down due to the pandemic.
By Cib, May 25, 2023 @ 10:58 pm

Die klassischen Lottozahlen vom Lotto 6aus49 werden bereits seit über 60 Jahren gezogen. Die Ziehungen finden immer mittwochs und samstags statt. In diese Seite findest du stets die aktuellen Lotto Ergebnisse. Um den Jackpot zu knacken, musst du 6 richtige Gewinnzahlen (aus 49) sowie die Superzahl auf deinem Lottoschein korrekt getippt haben. Im Lotto können Sie bis zu 43 Millionen Euro gewinnen. Der minimale Jackpot beträgt 1 Million Euro. Wenn der Jackpot nach 13 Ziehungen nicht gewonnen wird, wird die Zwangsauszahlung angewendet und der Jackpot geht an den glücklichen Gewinner in der unteren Gewinnklasse. Die Lottozahlen vom Eurojackpot werden von Spielern in insgesamt 18 Ländern verfolgt. Jeden Freitag findet die Ziehung in Helsinki statt, anschließend kannst du hier die Lottozahlen von Eurojackpot finden und mit deinem Lottoschein abgleichen. Um den Eurojackpot zu knacken, musst du 5 aus 50 Lottozahlen sowie 2 Eurozahlen auf deinem Lottoschein korrekt tippen. Im Eurojackpot können Sie bis zu 90 Millionen Euro gewinnen. Der minimale Jackpot beträgt 10 Millionen Euro.
http://www.kdri.co.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=458897
Treten Sie ein in die Welt der beliebtesten Casinospiele. In diesem Online-Casino können Sie Ihre Freizeit so genießen, wie Sie es wollen. Spielen Sie klassische Karten- und Tischspiele, Casino-Pokervarianten oder eine große Auswahl an Slots, darunter solche, die Sie nirgendwo sonst finden. Jedes Online-Casino, das Ihre Aufmerksamkeit verdient, verfügt über ein oder zwei Spielautomaten. Wir haben ein paar mehr. Slots gehören zu den beliebtesten Spielen der Welt und bei uns finden Sie alle Ihre Favoriten: ob klassischer Spielautomat oder ultramoderne Games voller Bonusfeatures. Treten Sie ein in die Welt der beliebtesten Casinospiele. In diesem Online-Casino können Sie Ihre Freizeit so genießen, wie Sie es wollen. Spielen Sie klassische Karten- und Tischspiele, Casino-Pokervarianten oder eine große Auswahl an Slots, darunter solche, die Sie nirgendwo sonst finden.
By bub, June 26, 2023 @ 8:21 pm

Discover the buzz of a real-life casino with our live casino games. If you are looking for an all-round immersive gambling experience, then the Gala casino review is just for you! Its immersive and diverse gaming catalogue, cutting-edge live casino lobby, and around-the-clock support are merely scratching the surface. Strap in and join the ride in the course of which we will uncover all the reasons why Gala is a fitting home for your gaming habits. Of course, like every other operator, Gala online casino has its setbacks as well. The number of games is very low and if you would like to play at a casino with over a thousand video slots, for example, you could try UK SlotsMillion Casino as well. Anyway, there are quite some popular and new titles at Gala Casino, which you will like a lot! As the commercial closes, people surrounding the main character applaud his efforts, and one of them takes a photo. The “Britain’s Got Talent” title referenced in the ad is a type of Slingo: a game that combines elements traditionally found in slots and bingo.
http://sqc.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=198
Crypto Reels Casino No Deposit Bonus =>Get 100 Free Spins Here! CRYPTOREELS CASINO REVIEW About When you visit the casino site that makes use of crypto, on making the… With so many choices of Online Casinos, it is often impossible to distinguish between the best and mediocre ones. Therefore, BonusManiac provided you a list of the TOP 20 Online Casinos, including everything you need to know about them. Here you can learn about online casinos with the best Payment Methods, website designs, Huge Bonuses, and various impressive features. A no deposit sign up bonus code for online casinos is pretty straightforward. Sign up with an online casino and get a real money bonus. There’s not much in the way of differences between the offers – so our rankings go beyond which online casino no deposit bonus gives you the biggest chunk of change. Other factors for determining the best no deposit bonus casinos are specific to the casinos themselves, including:
By Bob, September 5, 2023 @ 6:57 pm

GET THIS BONUS NOW! New post, moicuate2014 replied to Weekly Winners for June 12th The moment you sign up on the casino, each new member is entitled to the special tournaments. On each of the dollar wagered on the casino, each player gets just a point. On the weekly tournament, the players that get 1st, 2nd and 3rd position will be given $200, $100 and $50 respectively. Based on the information garnered from Thebes’s website, it began in 2008. Since there aren’t many online casinos then, it’s a good period for Thebes. The fact that the ten-year-old Thebes is still in existence leaves an impressive mark. It’s because most fraudulent casinos may not even last a year or two. Live Casino – Roulette, Lightning Roulette, Double Ball Roulette, Blackjack, Speed Blackjack, Casino Stud Poker, Caribbean Stud Poker, Casino Hold’Em Poker, Dragon Tiger, Punto Banco, Crazy Time, Dream Catcher, Deal Or No Deal, Side Bet City
https://forum.geographypoint.com/community/profile/tedsahurbuck197/
In the case of a Prospective Player, Intending Player, or a Player breaching or otherwise failing to comply with the terms and conditions of this Agreement, OLG will have the right to exercise any or all of the remedies described in this Agreement or otherwise available to it at law or in equity. Those remedies may include, for example, (i) the right to terminate a Prospective Player’s, Intending Player’s, or a Player’s eligibility to register or maintain a Player Account, (ii) to lock, Suspend, and or Deactivate a Player Account, and (iii) to retain any or all Unutilized Funds (as defined in Section 2 below) associated with a Player Account. No more long downloads. No more annoying updates. Just hop onto now.gg and get right into incredible mobile titles like POP! Slots, without the wait.