There was an interesting post at Debit vs. Credit two days ago suggesting that now may not be the time to buy a house. The gist of the argument was that house prices still have a way to go before they return to normal. This was illustrated with a chart of median new home prices as a ratio to median income since 1963. That’s not the most ideal set of data to use, for reasons that I will spare you.
The most useful measure of house prices are the S&P/Case-Shiller Home Price Indices. They only go back to 1987, but one of the co-inventors of the index, Robert Shiller, has chained together other useful house indexes to patch up a composite going back to 1890. (This is the third post that has mentioned Prof. Shiller in the past month. Just coincidence, I swear.)
I downloaded the data from his site, updated and cleaned up a few things, and produced the following chart, showing the inflation-adjusted sale price index for existing homes since 1890.
If you’ve never seen something like this before, you may be experiencing some shock and confusion. This is normal. Just keep breathing deeply. You thought house prices went up over time, didn’t you? Well, they do, but mostly because of inflation. Recent experience excepted, house prices are generally flat over long periods of time once inflation is factored out.
A few other observations worth making:
1) The last index value in this chart (which is for November 2008) is 144.0, still 13% higher than the 1989 peak of 127.4. That does suggest that we have a little more to go, or at least did as of November. On the other hand, it’s already down 40% from the 2005 peak of 202.5, so the worst may be behind us.
2) The recent run-up in house prices actually began in 1996. (From 1996 to 2005 real prices went up 86%.) It may not have gotten weird enough to be noticed in the media until the last years of the boom, but the index began hitting all-time highs as early as 2000. I mention this because it’s currently fashionable to blame the low interest rates of 2003-04 for the housing bubble. They sure didn’t help, but the worst you can say is that they were gasoline thrown on an already blazing fire.
3) As impressive as the 1996-2005 run up is, it is not entirely out of the ordinary. From 1942 to 1947, real house prices went up 60%, which is the best five year run in history. Further, prices pretty much stabilized after that and did not give back very much of the gain. This needs to be pointed out to those who say, in hindsight, that of course house prices had to fall after 2005, because the rapid gains made in years before were just unsustainable.
So is this a good time to buy a house? That depends. Do you need one to live in? There are many factors to consider, including interest rates, tax breaks and other incentives from the government, and local market conditions. (It is worth stating the possibly obvious that the chart above is a national average. Specifics of a particular area may differ both in the short and long run.)
But if you are looking at a house as a possibly shrewd investment, something you can buy cheap now and sell dear later on, you are likely to be disappointed. Even if the crisis were over today, and house prices returned to their pre-bubble habits, the normal state of things is that they don’t go up very much.