The Mortgage Interest Deduction Does Not Subsidize Lenders

There are days when I think I could rename this blog Stupid Things In SmartMoney and concentrate my efforts solely on that ironically Victorian House named publication. Today’s inspirationally bad offering is Mortgage Deduction Pads Lender Profits, in which we learn that “A tax perk aimed at homeowners ends up raising mortgage rates, research shows.”

Apparently, the mortgage interest deduction has the unintended consequence of driving up interest rates, harming those poor American homeowners it was meant to help. How does this happen? Well, here is where the story gets a little fuzzy.

Standard economics theory holds that consumer subsidies raise demand for goods, thereby shifting prices higher. With mortgages, the "price" is the interest rate.

I  can recast this in a way that almost makes sense. The mortgage interest deduction increases the value of houses, which increases the total amount borrowed with mortgages. That increased demand raises interest rates. But it would raise all interest rates, not just on mortgages but on credit cards and Treasury bonds too. It is a competitive marketplace, and all those potential loans are bidding for the same pool of potentially lent dollars.

But as theoretically sound as this reasoning might be, it seems pretty clear to me that the effect of the mortgage interest deduction on global interest rates is likely immeasurably small, particularly in light of the many other factors that affect those rates.

Enter the academic paper that SmartMoney reports on. The Incidence of the Mortgage Interest Deduction: Evidence from the Market for Home Purchase Loans by Andrew Hanson of the Economics Department of Georgia State University. Even in the context of some of the terrible papers I have discussed here, this one is a travesty.

The author’s approach is to examine interest rates on mortgages above and below the $1M ceiling on deductibility. His reasoning is that since only sub-$1M mortgages benefit from the subsidy, lower rates for bigger mortgages will show that the subsidy is driving up interest rates.

The problem with academics (and journalists) is that they often live lives sheltered from the realities of the marketplace. So they tend to miss points that are obvious to us poor slobs trying to make it in the real world. If you were a bank, why would you write a $1.5M mortgage at a lower rate than you could get on two $750K ones? Everything else equal, you would prefer the two smaller loans for diversification anyway.

Blithely ignoring the absence of reasoning that would support the effect he hopes to find, Hanson soldiers on looking for his snark. His next step is to use questionable data. He has a database of mortgages written in 2004, which is a little stale for a paper published this year, but that is forgivable. If the subsidy effect was there in 2004 it likely existed in other years.

What is not forgivable is that this data contains interest rate information only for loans where the rate was more than 3% above the equivalent Treasury rate. In other words, Hanson uses a skewed subset of mortgages that were particularly expensive and that make up just under 5% of the full database. Given that the mortgage interest rates were the subject of his study, this alone ought to have stopped him in his tracks.

A further problem is what the database lacks: information on the value of the house. Below the $1M limit, buyers have a strong incentive to borrow as much as the bank will let them have, even if they could otherwise put more cash down. So if you are buying a $500K house, you will borrow as much tax deductible interest money as you can, typically $400K, even if you had the full $500K in the bank. But if you are buying a $5M house, even if you can get a $4M mortgage, it is relatively expensive money and you are more likely to borrow less. Thus you would expect that higher mortgage values tended to have lower loan-to-value ratios, and thus lower interest rates.

Of course, Hanson carries on anyway, running quite a few regressions, some using the latest econometric techniques. And then he declares that the snark has been found. Interest rates are higher for the smaller mortgages, thus lenders are benefiting from the subsidy. “… Lending institutions capture between 9 and 17 percent of the subsidy created by the [mortgage interest deduction] in the form of higher interest rates.”

Except that, according to the numerical data in the paper, bigger loans were significantly more expensive. What Hanson actually found with his flawed data is that, everything else equal, mortgages over $1M had interest rates that were about 0.4% higher. Also, for every $100K of mortgage value, the rate was another 0.04% higher up to $1M, and then 0.01% higher per $100K after that.

Incredibly, it is that little kink in the line, the fact that the rate at which mortgages get more expensive slows above $1M, that allows Hanson to declare victory and spin his tale of banks capturing a subsidy meant for consumers.

To be fair, Hanson is just doing his job, albeit badly. His paper is not for general consumption. It is meant for other academics who understand the tables of numbers and equations he uses and can make their own informed judgments about his work.

SmartMoney, on the other hand, is for a general audience. It repeated to that audience a very poorly supported conclusion from an academic paper. Although I suppose it is possible that they did so knowing the conclusion was bogus because it supported some larger agenda, I doubt it. I believe they just reported on research that they did not understand nor were capable of evaluating.

(As an aside, as I have written before, I am no fan of the mortgage interest deduction. But I do not think we need to invent new reasons not to like it, particularly faux-populist anti-bank ones. All we really need is a way to gently wean ourselves from it without the dislocation that going cold turkey would bring. Gradually lowering the $1M limit over 10 or 20 years still works for me.)

categories Housing, Media | | datetime June 14, 2012 8:59 am

198 Comments

  • By Paul Williams, June 15, 2012 @ 12:17 pm

    I’m not a fan either, but do you really want to complicate our tax code further by adding another decreasing limit to the mess? Just scrap it all. Actually, scrap the whole tax code and come up with something simpler and cheaper to administrate.

Other Links to this Post

  1. countertop refinishing — March 10, 2023 @ 9:26 am

  2. promo products suppliers — March 10, 2023 @ 12:54 pm

  3. clock accessories — March 10, 2023 @ 2:29 pm

  4. gas fireplace repair service — March 10, 2023 @ 3:36 pm

  5. embroidered hats — March 10, 2023 @ 4:26 pm

  6. tub restoration — March 10, 2023 @ 4:27 pm

  7. get redirected here — March 10, 2023 @ 10:06 pm

  8. chimney repair peoria — March 11, 2023 @ 4:44 am

  9. personal promotional products — March 11, 2023 @ 5:41 am

  10. All Valley Fireplace Repair — March 11, 2023 @ 11:19 am

  11. read more — March 11, 2023 @ 12:28 pm

  12. tub and tile reglazing near me — March 11, 2023 @ 1:38 pm

  13. embroidered hats — March 11, 2023 @ 4:27 pm

  14. chimney fireplace repair — March 11, 2023 @ 5:51 pm

  15. DIY clock hands repair — March 11, 2023 @ 6:44 pm

  16. promotional products — March 11, 2023 @ 7:17 pm

  17. refinish bathtub near me — March 11, 2023 @ 8:40 pm

  18. gas fireplace repairman near me — March 12, 2023 @ 12:24 am

  19. Clock kits and dials — March 12, 2023 @ 1:47 am

  20. countertop refinishing — March 12, 2023 @ 3:44 am

  21. luggage tags — March 12, 2023 @ 6:28 am

  22. useful reference — March 12, 2023 @ 6:55 am

  23. time movement hands — March 12, 2023 @ 8:50 am

  24. clock inserts suppliers — March 12, 2023 @ 3:50 pm

  25. tile refinishing near me — March 12, 2023 @ 5:29 pm

  26. corporate gifts — March 12, 2023 @ 9:52 pm

  27. bathroom resurfacing near me — March 13, 2023 @ 12:36 am

  28. custom surgical masks — March 13, 2023 @ 4:47 am

  29. customized water bottles — March 13, 2023 @ 1:45 pm

  30. labor day weekend music festival — March 13, 2023 @ 2:47 pm

  31. branded face masks — March 13, 2023 @ 4:14 pm

  32. how to replace clock hands — March 13, 2023 @ 6:31 pm

  33. Best digital clocks — March 13, 2023 @ 6:39 pm

  34. parts of a clock — March 13, 2023 @ 6:43 pm

  35. self storage units near me — March 13, 2023 @ 7:53 pm

  36. custom printed signage — March 13, 2023 @ 11:01 pm

  37. public address transmitter software — March 14, 2023 @ 1:06 am

  38. clock Inserts videos — March 14, 2023 @ 1:29 am

  39. camper storage — March 14, 2023 @ 2:07 am

  40. branded face masks — March 14, 2023 @ 2:17 am

  41. badge reels — March 14, 2023 @ 5:24 am

  42. wireless synchronized clocks — March 14, 2023 @ 7:14 am

  43. metal clock hands — March 14, 2023 @ 7:26 am

  44. visit website here — March 14, 2023 @ 7:52 am

  45. large storage units — March 14, 2023 @ 8:15 am

  46. Homepage — March 14, 2023 @ 9:48 am

  47. safety kits — March 14, 2023 @ 11:49 am

  48. outdoor clocks for business — March 14, 2023 @ 1:26 pm

  49. clock repair videos — March 14, 2023 @ 1:40 pm

  50. imprinted safety glasses — March 14, 2023 @ 2:14 pm

  51. custom printed signage — March 14, 2023 @ 6:31 pm

  52. wireless products — March 14, 2023 @ 8:02 pm

  53. metal clock hands — March 14, 2023 @ 8:34 pm

  54. americana music festivals — March 14, 2023 @ 11:03 pm

  55. tradeshow signs — March 15, 2023 @ 1:57 am

  56. metal clock mechanism — March 15, 2023 @ 3:48 am

  57. storage units missoula mt — March 15, 2023 @ 4:21 am

  58. clock inserts suppliers — March 15, 2023 @ 4:43 am

  59. americana music festival colorado — March 15, 2023 @ 6:12 am

  60. custom logo design — March 15, 2023 @ 9:20 am

  61. get more info — March 15, 2023 @ 10:19 am

  62. hour hands for clocks — March 15, 2023 @ 10:53 am

  63. storage facility — March 15, 2023 @ 11:13 am

  64. americana music festival 2023 — March 15, 2023 @ 1:23 pm

  65. first aid kits — March 15, 2023 @ 4:03 pm

  66. Click Here — March 15, 2023 @ 4:45 pm

  67. public address transmitters — March 15, 2023 @ 5:29 pm

  68. Big clock parts — March 15, 2023 @ 6:02 pm

  69. storage unit — March 15, 2023 @ 6:05 pm

  70. clock inserts movements — March 15, 2023 @ 8:00 pm

  71. red rock colorado music festival — March 15, 2023 @ 8:31 pm

  72. printed water bottles — March 15, 2023 @ 10:30 pm

  73. trailer storage near me — March 16, 2023 @ 12:59 am

  74. how to build your own clock — March 16, 2023 @ 1:12 am

  75. replacement parts for clocks — March 16, 2023 @ 3:44 am

  76. promotional products — March 16, 2023 @ 4:58 am

  77. synchronized wireless clocks — March 16, 2023 @ 7:48 am

  78. self storage units near me — March 16, 2023 @ 7:53 am

  79. clock dial face fit ups — March 16, 2023 @ 8:23 am

  80. monument lake resort music festival — March 16, 2023 @ 11:09 am

  81. reusable face masks — March 16, 2023 @ 11:17 am

  82. missoula storage unit prices — March 16, 2023 @ 2:50 pm

  83. synchronized clocks for stadiums — March 16, 2023 @ 2:59 pm

  84. promotional items — March 16, 2023 @ 3:03 pm

  85. labor day weekend music festival — March 16, 2023 @ 6:29 pm

  86. clock hands repair — March 16, 2023 @ 6:52 pm

  87. wireless communication systems — March 16, 2023 @ 10:26 pm

  88. weston colorado caveman music festival — March 17, 2023 @ 1:45 am

  89. self storage near me — March 17, 2023 @ 4:44 am

  90. clocks large facilities — March 17, 2023 @ 5:39 am

  91. corporate gifts — March 17, 2023 @ 5:56 am

  92. imprinted knee pads — March 17, 2023 @ 6:18 am

  93. metal hands — March 17, 2023 @ 6:29 am

  94. americana music festival colorado — March 17, 2023 @ 9:05 am

  95. metal clock hands — March 17, 2023 @ 9:52 am

  96. missoula storage units — March 17, 2023 @ 11:42 am

  97. Building management services — March 17, 2023 @ 12:55 pm

  98. engraved pens — March 17, 2023 @ 1:18 pm

  99. monument lake resort music festival — March 17, 2023 @ 4:23 pm

  100. storage units near me — March 17, 2023 @ 6:37 pm

  101. promo products suppliers — March 17, 2023 @ 7:01 pm

  102. wireless clocks sync — March 17, 2023 @ 8:22 pm

  103. clock making replacement parts — March 17, 2023 @ 9:38 pm

  104. americana festival 2023 — March 17, 2023 @ 11:36 pm

  105. best motor for clocks — March 18, 2023 @ 12:45 am

  106. promotional products — March 18, 2023 @ 1:16 am

  107. motorhome storage near me — March 18, 2023 @ 1:32 am

  108. auto sync clocks — March 18, 2023 @ 3:41 am

  109. customized water bottles — March 18, 2023 @ 3:50 am

  110. metal clock mechanism — March 18, 2023 @ 5:06 am

  111. music festival — March 18, 2023 @ 6:46 am

  112. customized lanyards — March 18, 2023 @ 7:29 am

  113. plastic dial hand — March 18, 2023 @ 7:59 am

  114. indoor rv storage near me — March 18, 2023 @ 8:21 am

  115. hospital clock system — March 18, 2023 @ 10:46 am

  116. read more — March 18, 2023 @ 12:14 pm

  117. personalised engraved pens — March 18, 2023 @ 1:39 pm

  118. missoula self storage — March 18, 2023 @ 2:54 pm

  119. sync system clock — March 18, 2023 @ 6:02 pm

  120. clock movement — March 18, 2023 @ 7:22 pm

  121. caveman live music americana festival — March 18, 2023 @ 8:58 pm

  122. metal water bottles — March 19, 2023 @ 1:08 am

  123. custom printed face masks — March 19, 2023 @ 2:01 am

  124. clock hands repair — March 19, 2023 @ 5:11 am

  125. elapsed time clock for operating rooms — March 19, 2023 @ 8:42 am

  126. parts of a clock — March 19, 2023 @ 9:33 am

  127. clock accessories — March 19, 2023 @ 12:13 pm

  128. personalised engraved pens — March 19, 2023 @ 2:20 pm

  129. clock mechanisms — March 19, 2023 @ 4:40 pm

  130. cheapest storage units near me — March 19, 2023 @ 6:00 pm

  131. americana music festival colorado — March 19, 2023 @ 6:43 pm

  132. mechanisms for clocks — March 19, 2023 @ 7:19 pm

  133. sync system clock — March 19, 2023 @ 11:25 pm

  134. jazz music festival — March 20, 2023 @ 1:52 am

  135. replacement parts for clocks — March 20, 2023 @ 2:25 am

  136. branded products — March 20, 2023 @ 5:32 am

  137. read more — March 20, 2023 @ 6:37 am

  138. missoula boat storage — March 20, 2023 @ 8:31 am

  139. best americana music festivals — March 20, 2023 @ 9:19 am

  140. DIY clock replacement parts — March 20, 2023 @ 9:27 am

  141. Printed Gear — March 20, 2023 @ 2:10 pm

  142. PA systems — March 20, 2023 @ 2:18 pm

  143. rv storage near me — March 20, 2023 @ 4:01 pm

  144. best motor for clocks — March 20, 2023 @ 4:27 pm

  145. imprinted knee pads — March 20, 2023 @ 8:05 pm

  146. clock repair parts — March 20, 2023 @ 8:30 pm

  147. americana music festival colorado 2023 — March 21, 2023 @ 12:01 am

  148. custom lanyards — March 21, 2023 @ 2:00 am

  149. Click Here — March 21, 2023 @ 3:02 am

  150. parts of a clock — March 21, 2023 @ 3:21 am

  151. best clock movements — March 21, 2023 @ 6:40 am

  152. trailer storage — March 21, 2023 @ 6:49 am

  153. read more — March 21, 2023 @ 7:52 am

  154. Learn More — March 21, 2023 @ 10:07 am

  155. custom logo design — March 21, 2023 @ 1:41 pm

  156. motorhome storage near me — March 21, 2023 @ 2:14 pm

  157. labor day weekend music festival — March 21, 2023 @ 2:14 pm

  158. clock synchronization software — March 21, 2023 @ 7:07 pm

  159. Click Here — March 21, 2023 @ 7:31 pm

  160. u.s. music festivals — March 21, 2023 @ 9:24 pm

  161. click Here — March 21, 2023 @ 11:56 pm

  162. badge reels — March 22, 2023 @ 12:45 am

  163. outdoor clocks for hospitals — March 22, 2023 @ 2:19 am

  164. how to replace clock hands — March 22, 2023 @ 3:57 am

  165. caveman music americana festival — March 22, 2023 @ 4:48 am

  166. read more — March 22, 2023 @ 6:47 am

  167. custom surgical masks — March 22, 2023 @ 7:31 am

  168. reusable face masks — March 22, 2023 @ 8:11 am

  169. storage near me — March 22, 2023 @ 12:21 pm

  170. customized water bottles — March 22, 2023 @ 1:38 pm

  171. clock movement — March 22, 2023 @ 6:19 pm

  172. corporate gifts — March 22, 2023 @ 7:40 pm

  173. missoula storage units — March 22, 2023 @ 7:44 pm

  174. music festival — March 22, 2023 @ 7:49 pm

  175. mechanism for clocks — March 22, 2023 @ 8:34 pm

  176. branded face masks — March 22, 2023 @ 10:56 pm

  177. large clock hands — March 23, 2023 @ 1:17 am

  178. wholesale promotional products — March 23, 2023 @ 1:25 am

  179. mini storage near me — March 23, 2023 @ 3:00 am

  180. monument lake resort music festival — March 23, 2023 @ 3:05 am

  181. clocks for hospitals — March 23, 2023 @ 6:54 am

  182. Click Here — March 23, 2023 @ 7:05 am

  183. mechanisms for clocks — March 23, 2023 @ 10:12 am

  184. utility trailer storage — March 23, 2023 @ 10:22 am

  185. monument lake resort americana festival — March 23, 2023 @ 10:35 am

  186. branded face masks — March 23, 2023 @ 12:45 pm

  187. customized water bottles — March 23, 2023 @ 1:40 pm

  188. replacement parts for clocks — March 23, 2023 @ 3:34 pm

  189. clock mechanisms — March 23, 2023 @ 5:10 pm

  190. weston colorado caveman music festival — March 23, 2023 @ 6:07 pm

  191. logo printed face masks — March 23, 2023 @ 6:30 pm

  192. gas fireplace services — March 23, 2023 @ 8:28 pm

  193. synchronized Hospital clocks — March 23, 2023 @ 8:43 pm

  194. clock movement — March 24, 2023 @ 2:36 am

  195. bathtub reglazing san fernando valley — March 24, 2023 @ 3:11 am

  196. gas fireplace repairman near me — March 24, 2023 @ 4:32 am

  197. synchronized wireless clocks — March 24, 2023 @ 4:41 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

WordPress Themes