Crazy Cell Phone Contracts for Crazy Americans
Would you rather pay $399 now and $20 a month for two years, or $199 now and $30 a month for two years? If you are a rational consumer, you probably prefer the $399 deal. The other one is like a $200 loan at 20% interest.
And yet, according to a long and meandering article from yesterday’s New York Times on the madness of cell phone pricing schemes, we wacky Americans preferred the iPhone at $199 with a $30 data plan over the previous deal of $399 with a $20 plan. I’m not sure I buy that. iPhone sales could have increased for a number of reasons, including the fact that the $199 phone was an upgraded version. Still, the Times piece does bring up a number of peculiarities about the economics of cell phones.
In case you live in a cave, I’ll explain that here in the Land of the Free we "buy" heavily subsidized cell phones from the companies who run the cell phone networks and in exchange agree to a service contract with that network, generally for two years. The cell phone company takes a loss on the phone and makes it up on the service end.
Even within our complex consumer culture, that’s a fairly unique way to pay for something. It would be like Exxon selling cars at a big discount if you promised to buy their gas at $5 a gallon. The closest analogue I can think of is the classic razors/razorblades or printers/printer cartridges strategy.
But that’s not quite the same thing. When you buy a printer you are not contractually obligated to buy a certain number of ink cartridges. You can stop using the printer any time you want. And the manufacturer is banking on the assumption that you will underestimate how many cartridges you will buy in the future.
With cell phones, you know how much you will be forced to pay over two years. That means it should be very easy to work out what a phone will cost in total. So why bother with the subsidy and contract thing?
(The Times says what I thought to be true, that this is a uniquely American method and that those sensible Europeans buy phones like any other electronic gadget and pay for service separately. I mentioned this to the German teenager who lives in my house and she looked at me like I had two heads. Turns out, Germans buy subsidized cell phones on contracts too.)
I think that we pay for cell phones the way we do because of a combination of convention and mental accounting. Cell phones are phones, after all, and as we all know, you pay for phones monthly. Comparing an ongoing monthly expense to a lump sum requires the use of math and some knowledge of finance. Yuck.
And it’s not just the math. We don’t like moving things from one mental bucket to another and changing from monthly to lump sum just upsets the way we think about our money. For example, ask yourself this: which has more appeal, investing $1000 in a CD that paid 4% or $1000 in new appliances for your home that would save you $3.50 a month in utility bills? The appliance deal is a little better, but not as attractive to most people because swapping savings for lower ongoing payments isn’t something we like to do.
This only scratches the surface of the oddities of the cell phone business. The Times also mentions, but does not really discuss, consumer preferences for buying a maximum number of minutes rather than paying for actual use and the fact that providing cell phone service on the margin costs essentially nothing. It does not even bring up how or why ATT will give you a phone for free by charging you $50 and rebating that back in the form of a gift card.
The article did have one disturbing tidbit. The average American cell phone user sent 518 text messages a month in the first half of this year. That’s more than 17 a day. Average. I’ve never felt so old.
73 Comments
Other Links to this Post
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
By Neil, November 16, 2009 @ 4:05 pm
Hardly a uniquely American problem. Everywhere I’ve spent time, there’ve been these sorts of cell phone deals. Their popularity varies a lot by country, and the US is unusually prone to buying them.
Still, I can understand it. When I trade money today for reduced future payments, I need a pretty quick payback period. Switching to a prepaid cell phone took only 3 months to recover my costs, so was completely worth it. I had, however declined the same deal a year earlier (when it first became available) because of the penalty for breaking my existing contract made it take 10 months to recover my costs.
And finally, your appliance example is a poor one. The extra $2 per year that your theoretical person is saving comes at the cost of liquidity, so the CD’s “premium” is completely rational.
By Rob Bennett, November 16, 2009 @ 4:14 pm
The people trying to sell us stuff understand well that emotion dominates in money decisions.
The people who give us money advice assume rationality in most of the guidelines they offer.
Many bemoan the fact that we save and invest so ineffectively.
Rob
By TFB, November 17, 2009 @ 1:56 am
I still prefer $1,000 in a CD than $1,000 in new appliance because the appliance depreciates much faster than cash. After 5 years, I still have $1,000 whereas the $1,000 appliance will probably be worth $300.
By Phil, November 17, 2009 @ 6:03 am
The appliance buying analogy applies to readers of your site – not most Americans who would opt charge to a credit card some shiny new gadget vs save any day.
By kosmo @ The Casual Observer, November 17, 2009 @ 9:55 am
I won’t argue with your logic, but your interest rate is wrong. $200 now vs. $10 a month for 24 months is not 20% APR
By Frank Curmudgeon, November 17, 2009 @ 10:11 am
Sorry. I meant 18.5%. Which is a little like 20%.
By kosmo @ The Casual Observer, November 17, 2009 @ 10:49 am
The 20% extra you’re paying (240 vs. 200) is split over TWO years. So the APR is half that.
By Frank Curmudgeon, November 17, 2009 @ 6:38 pm
Well, no. The “loan” is paid off over two years but it’s half gone after a year or so, meaning that the average balance over the period is about $100. A $200 loan at 18.5% will amortize at $10 a month over two years. Try it in Excel.
By Kosmo @ The Casual Observer, November 17, 2009 @ 9:38 pm
Lol. I stand corrected. I was using simply TVM rather than amortization/annuity. Guess it’s a bad Monday for me. Er, Tuesday
By TJR, November 18, 2009 @ 6:02 am
Turns out those Germans *can* buy phone and service separately, and it is becoming increasingly popular to do so. The plans are often called “Pre-paid”, “Mobilfunk-Discounter” etc.
Turns out those Belgians even cannot get phones subsidised by law.
By MJM, November 18, 2009 @ 6:11 pm
While your math in general may be accurate, once you factor in the present value of your payments, you’re only saving $30 (@1%), so the decision is not as “crazy” as you point out.
By zach, November 19, 2009 @ 2:11 am
After spending a year living in Sweden, I can tell you that there is an option for a contract and when Telia landed the iphone exclusively, people had to get it at a 2-year contract. My girlfriend at the time worked for Telia.
That aside, I found like myself, that a large part of the population uses the prepaid phone. Oh and their service makes the US look third-word. All incoming calls and messages are free. like 2cents for everything out and 5cents to land..What’s att doing 25cents? 10 if you prepay enough minutes?
But that is also why residents there get 100mb internet connections for 1/4 the cost of verizons BRAND NEW 50mb FIOS network!!!
By Amanda Bidyes, November 23, 2009 @ 11:48 am
The phone company makes the profit as soon as you pay $200 for an Iphone. I have a phone with maximum minutes, I pay monthly and got the phone for free. A touch phone.
Anyway, about buying the phone with the loan. I guess some people just want to have the phone and can’t pay the full amount up front. Goot for them.
By Attorney, December 15, 2011 @ 1:02 am
The reason many European countries don’t offer the service contract for discounted cellphones have to do with the anti-trust laws there. In America, two companies can cooperate to have their products “packaged” together if they are related to each other. Ie: cellphones and mobile phone services. In Europe, the antitrust laws are stricter in many nation states so this would be deemed illegal tying.
By Dong Morley, August 2, 2013 @ 7:42 am
Many thanks for this put up! Some seriously inspriational designs here. LC
By Darrel Joshlin, August 11, 2013 @ 5:52 am
It�s onerous to seek out knowledgeable individuals on this matter, but you sound like you realize what you�re talking about! Thanks
By Cathern Gorczynski, August 12, 2013 @ 3:21 am
After I initially commented I clicked the -Notify me when new feedback are added- checkbox and now every time a remark is added I get 4 emails with the identical comment. Is there any means you may take away me from that service? Thanks!
By cheap nfl jerseys, September 5, 2013 @ 11:04 pm
Once we have previously considered the nike air jordan agency only releases these footwear on a specific date of the year, this keeps a low supply very popular. It is obvious that the involving Air Jordans on offer will not becoming very high when you go online and come across the right badly designed web property which sells Nike shoes you likely will easily be place to deduct that item being sold is really a fake if you will find claims to have thousands in stocks and sell the parties at a minimal price. when these sneakers and in addition go on dealing their price levels between 50 coupled with $70 however, much like the version they may go as the highest as $300+ and a case of this Air Jordan 3.
By コーチメンズ, September 5, 2013 @ 11:04 pm
A set of nike air jordan XI Cool Grey 11 Space Jam 3 shoes are always going for $325.00 during eBay — and also a pair of 2009 Nike Air The air jordan 11 Retro XI Concord shoes become listed at $219.99 at the opportunity.
By Dbzrlh, May 11, 2023 @ 9:36 pm
cialis 20mg ca order tadalafil 40mg sale buy ed pills fda
By Zsdien, May 20, 2023 @ 12:51 pm
accutane order online accutane without prescription zithromax 500mg brand
By Rtqqrt, May 22, 2023 @ 5:20 am
azithromycin 250mg usa prednisolone 40mg generic buy neurontin tablets
By Vkllrq, May 24, 2023 @ 12:16 am
buy generic lasix 40mg buy doxycycline tablets purchase ventolin inhalator online
By Svtomd, May 25, 2023 @ 3:54 pm
cheap ramipril 5mg cheap etoricoxib 60mg arcoxia 60mg brand
By Oheknd, May 25, 2023 @ 5:39 pm
levitra without prescription order plaquenil 400mg sale order plaquenil sale
By Nujyir, June 15, 2023 @ 1:06 pm
buy tetracycline 250mg online buy flexeril cheap baclofen order online
By Gfcasa, June 15, 2023 @ 3:51 pm
order ampicillin 500mg online buy cipro generic buy flagyl 400mg for sale
By Rhtjav, June 17, 2023 @ 2:35 am
buy cheap toradol toradol medication generic inderal 10mg
By Fdtouj, June 17, 2023 @ 11:45 am
purchase bactrim cleocin 150mg brand clindamycin without prescription
By Shmtur, June 18, 2023 @ 4:50 pm
plavix where to buy buy plavix 75mg online warfarin uk
By Hzkycv, June 19, 2023 @ 8:02 am
erythromycin uk nolvadex order buy nolvadex generic
By Kgjwwa, June 20, 2023 @ 7:28 am
reglan uk order esomeprazole 40mg capsules esomeprazole over the counter
By Xcmgft, June 21, 2023 @ 5:25 am
buy budesonide generic bimatoprost without prescription bimatoprost usa
By Enekqk, June 22, 2023 @ 12:10 am
topiramate drug how to get topiramate without a prescription buy levofloxacin cheap
By Ectmml, June 23, 2023 @ 1:57 am
cost methocarbamol 500mg robaxin 500mg price sildenafil 100mg usa
By Sujgnw, June 23, 2023 @ 3:01 pm
avodart for sale buy generic zantac mobic online order
By Lltzyr, June 24, 2023 @ 10:41 pm
order generic sildenafil order sildenafil 50mg buy estrace 1mg online
By Iaulfx, June 25, 2023 @ 5:08 am
buy celecoxib pill tamsulosin 0.4mg pills order ondansetron 8mg online
By Kwhktg, June 26, 2023 @ 8:37 pm
buy aldactone 100mg online spironolactone uk valtrex ca
By Jurxzf, June 26, 2023 @ 11:03 pm
order lamotrigine generic order lamictal 50mg pills prazosin 2mg drug
By Jqygan, June 28, 2023 @ 11:20 am
propecia 1mg canada order finasteride 5mg for sale sildenafil australia
By Vhlbkm, June 29, 2023 @ 12:19 am
order tretinoin cream generic order avanafil 100mg online cheap avana 100mg oral
By Wplvxd, July 30, 2023 @ 11:41 am
calcitriol 0.25 mg for sale calcitriol 0.25mg over the counter tricor 200mg pills
By Ghohwg, July 31, 2023 @ 6:10 pm
order dexamethasone without prescription starlix 120 mg usa buy nateglinide 120 mg generic
By Kbtthy, August 1, 2023 @ 5:35 pm
buy oxcarbazepine 600mg without prescription buy generic uroxatral for sale buy generic urso for sale
By Moozum, September 2, 2023 @ 9:17 pm
purchase prasugrel pills prasugrel for sale tolterodine 2mg tablet
By Ujiqoj, September 5, 2023 @ 9:59 pm
purchase ferrous sale ferrous 100mg over the counter buy sotalol 40mg generic
By Ecdseq, September 6, 2023 @ 7:06 am
mestinon pills how to buy rizatriptan oral rizatriptan 10mg
By Hneedy, October 9, 2023 @ 5:03 am
purchase lioresal for sale order baclofen 25mg generic ketorolac price
By Vmctrs, October 9, 2023 @ 6:53 pm
buy claritin generic generic dapoxetine buy priligy 30mg pill
By Mqntjc, October 11, 2023 @ 5:03 am
lioresal order online buy generic lioresal online buy ketorolac generic
By Bhwjml, October 12, 2023 @ 5:20 pm
glimepiride over the counter etoricoxib uk arcoxia 120mg sale
By Jflaan, October 13, 2023 @ 4:02 am
order alendronate 35mg for sale fosamax 70mg uk buy furadantin 100mg for sale
By Axiyej, October 15, 2023 @ 11:25 am
inderal 20mg sale order inderal pill order clopidogrel 75mg generic
By Fgxwie, October 17, 2023 @ 6:05 pm
nortriptyline pills acetaminophen 500 mg without prescription buy paracetamol 500mg sale
By Pykfpf, October 19, 2023 @ 8:56 pm
buy warfarin without a prescription paroxetine medication buy reglan 10mg online cheap
By Lqqpyb, October 20, 2023 @ 6:01 am
order xenical sale diltiazem 180mg drug buy generic diltiazem
By Fjyduc, October 23, 2023 @ 10:15 am
order pepcid 40mg without prescription tacrolimus 1mg pills order tacrolimus 5mg sale
By Qddapv, October 24, 2023 @ 12:16 pm
generic astelin acyclovir tablet avalide brand
By Wtrnhf, October 26, 2023 @ 1:38 pm
purchase nexium without prescription buy mirtazapine 15mg for sale order topiramate generic
By Wuyipu, October 28, 2023 @ 8:39 pm
oral zyloprim 300mg cheap zyloprim 300mg crestor for sale
By Uqyltz, October 28, 2023 @ 8:49 pm
order sumatriptan 50mg pill buy dutasteride cheap cheap avodart 0.5mg
By Pwfkjs, October 30, 2023 @ 7:46 am
zantac online mobic online order buy celecoxib cheap
By Auto Glass Replacement In 27587, April 30, 2024 @ 5:26 pm
The thoughtful analysis has really made me think. Thanks for the great read!
By Colettedub, June 10, 2024 @ 1:37 pm
CBD exceeded my expectations in every way thanks 300mg cbd gummies . I’ve struggled with insomnia in the interest years, and after infuriating CBD for the prime age, I at the last moment practised a complete nightfall of pacific sleep. It was like a arrange had been lifted misled my shoulders. The calming effects were calm after all scholarly, allowing me to inclination off naturally without sensibilities punchy the next morning. I also noticed a reduction in my daytime desire, which was an unexpected but welcome bonus. The cultivation was a flash earthy, but nothing intolerable. Whole, CBD has been a game-changer for my slumber and solicitude issues, and I’m appreciative to have discovered its benefits.
By Gaston Morini, June 30, 2024 @ 7:44 pm
http://idea.informer.com/users/sushiturkey35/?what=personal
By Novella Whisker, July 1, 2024 @ 1:52 am
https://btpars.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=3273433
By Stacy Harcus, July 1, 2024 @ 10:33 pm
https://firewar888.tw/home.php?mod=space&uid=643445
By Emmanuel Ouimet, July 2, 2024 @ 6:12 am
https://humanlove.stream/wiki/Shattered_Perspectives_A_Guide_to_Auto_Glass_Replacement
By Alfred Clute, July 2, 2024 @ 7:58 pm
https://www.google.fm/url?q=https://canvas.instructure.com/eportfolios/2943100/Home/Clear_as_Glass_The_Ultimate_Guide_to_Auto_Glass_Replacement
By Ernesto Koistinen, July 5, 2024 @ 9:50 pm
http://120.zsluoping.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=634279
By Kelly Hengel, August 27, 2024 @ 9:51 pm
Bookmarking this! The practical advice is something I’ll definitely be coming back to.
By ремонт техники в москве, September 10, 2024 @ 6:42 am
Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту бытовой техники с выездом на дом.
Мы предлагаем: сервис центры бытовой техники москва
Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом!