Home Prices Turn Up
Yesterday, being the last Tuesday of June, was, obviously, the day they released the April Standard & Poor’s/Case Shiller Home Price Index numbers. If you are a regular reader of this blog you know I think this is just about the only useful data we get on the housing market. And house prices aren’t just important to us consumer-homeowners, they are central to the whole Great Recession thing.
Judging by Tuesday afternoon headlines, the data wasn’t so good. "U.S. Home Price Declines Moderating, Index Says" leads the story in The New York Times. The Wall Street Journal has "Home Prices Drop at Slower Pace", Bloomberg tells us "Home-Price Slide Eases" and the Boston Globe carries a story with the headline "Home prices post 18.1 percent annual drop in April".
I include what my increasingly pathetic hometown paper said (it was just running the AP story) because:
1. An "18.1 percent annual drop" would mean to most people that April was down from March on an annualized rate at 18.1%, not, as they meant, down 18.1% from April 2008. In this case that’s a big difference. April was down –0.6% from March, which annualizes to –7%. Not that you had any chance to work that out for yourself, as the monthly number is not in the AP story.
2. House prices here in Boston were actually up 0.4% for the month, a fact you might think they’d sneak into the story somewhere. Perhaps it’s in today’s paper edition. I haven’t looked.
Overall, from the headlines and body of these stories a reasonable person would get the feeling that the reporters were trying very hard to positively spin a grim situation. We’re still going to hell in a hand basket, but more slowly than before. This coordination in message is not a conspiracy. All the stories are written based on the press release from S&P, and it was headlined "The Pace of Home Price Declines Moderate in April".
Trust no one and check the math.
Thankfully for us cynical geeks, in addition to the press release S&P makes available the index numbers in a spreadsheet. Download that, do some lightweight analysis, and you will find that the story is a lot more cheerful than the media would have you believe.
Firstly, the monthly decline really is a lot more moderate than it has been recently. It was down more than 2% in each of the six months from October ’08 to March ’09. And 8 of the 20 cities in the composite were up for April, which is better than the 3 in March and much better than the zero for each of the six months before that.
And then there is New York. The Big Apple is a bit of a special case because it has economic problems that are directly tied to the implosion of Wall Street in a way that the rest of the country’s are not. After holding on pretty well through the early years of the national decline, NYC house prices were down just -14.7% from July ’06 to December ’08 versus –27.1% nationally, they’ve been keeping up with national declines this year and were down –1.7% in April. (And the other way that New York is special is that its housing market it dominated by apartments, which are not included in the Case-Shiller indexes at all.)
But New York is also the largest weight in the 20 City Composite, at 19.4%. I am not suggesting that the 20 City Index isn’t the definitive and legitimate benchmark, but by my calculations the 19 City Ex-NYC Index was down only –0.3% for the month, i.e. New York alone represented almost half the national decline.
Moreover, as I mentioned in my last update on house prices, what S&P calls monthly numbers aren’t. These are the monthly updates of a series of three month moving averages. So what they call the April number is really the February-March-April number and the monthly changes are not March to April but January-February-March to February-March-April.
Do a little algebra and you realize that Feb/Mar/Apr vs. Jan/Feb/Mar is really April compared to January. Do more algebra and you will work out that if the three month moving average was declining at -2% a month for six months, and then lightened to –0.6%, it is very likely that the actual month over month number, April vs. March, which S&P does not disclose, was positive.
Now it must be pointed out that a similar moderation in the rate of decline of house prices happened last summer. The June ’08 index number was down only –0.5% and it looked a lot like things were turning around, just as it does now. Then the credit crisis hit and we got another wave of pain. So anything’s possible, but, as uncurmudgeonly as it is, I find myself rather optimistic on house prices just now.
And I’m not alone. The Shiller in Case-Shiller gave an interview yesterday on Bloomberg (long but worth it) in which he was, by his dour standards, almost giddy.
75 Comments
Other Links to this Post
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
By Jon @capitalistmaven.com, July 1, 2009 @ 9:27 am
I believe there should be a corrective factor thrown in for the recent government intervention in the housing market. Just like seasonally adjusted numbers, there should be bailout adjusted numbers. You cannot discount the fact that many sales were adjusted +$8,000 higher by the stimuli. In many areas, this is almost a 10% positive effect on prices. While this number is probably between 1 and 2% for Boston, it still serves to adjust your +0.4% number into -0.6% to -1.6%. Come January 2010, if the stimuli is not extended or even increased as is being suggested, expect this -$8,000 to show up in the data as an “unexpected” large drop in monthly numbers…
By gpr, July 1, 2009 @ 10:39 am
It’s astonishing that even after all these years, those two little clauses can cause my pulse to quicken.
Frank – still enjoying this blog. Even (or maybe especially) when it makes me scratch my head and re-read more slowly.
Fascinating stuff.
By Jim, July 1, 2009 @ 2:44 pm
They don’t seem to adjust it to seasonal cycles. An uptick in spring is expected with housing sales. There is a regular seasonal pattern in the month to month home sale prices. In the winter and fall prices do not go up as much on average. Then come spring prices start to jump and keep climbing through the summer. This is because people buy/sell homes much more during spring and summer than in winter.
If you look at the Composite-20 index you can see the seasonal fluctuation in month to month % changes. Prices jump a bit more usually in the spring and don’t go up as much in the winter.
On average since 2000 price changes per month were:
January -0.3%
February -0.1%
March 0.3%
April 0.7%
May 0.9%
June 0.9%
July 0.7%
August 0.5%
September 0.3%
October 0.1%
November -0.1%
December -0.2%
The S&P press release says: “We are entering the seasonally strong period in the housing market, so it will take some time to determine if a recovery is really here.” So they aren’t sure if the uptick in April is just the arrival of summer or if its a start of the recovery.
By Wapner PC, July 1, 2009 @ 7:48 pm
Your report on AP based articles in the press extends far beyond housing reports. Newspapers can blame the internet for their demise but they need to look in the mirror and realize that crappy reporting on a universal scale is equally responsible. I have turned to blogs for intelligent discourse on events.
By Kent @ The Financial Philosopher, July 3, 2009 @ 2:07 pm
Great points, Frank. Algebra was not my best subject (it was philosophy), but thankfully one does not need Algebra to be a “cynical geek!”
With regard to mainstream media, one only needs to understand their primary motive — to sell advertising. This makes their capacity to provide useful information (absent of emotion-provoking headlines) nearly impossible.
Simply stop consuming mainstream media and there is no need to do the Algebra!
“There is no truth, only perception.” ~ Friedrich Nietzsche
By Panele Fotowoltaiczne, August 12, 2013 @ 11:47 am
I think that this it’s a very readable concept and I agree with you. This post has truly rich my knowledge and experience, I’m glad. I found this site and I can share with you my observations and thoughts. If you have new solutions or concept, please send me a notice by email.
By alex been, April 29, 2023 @ 6:07 pm
If in conjuring Du Bois, powell and Menendian suggest that we arenow in another phase of the problem of the color line, then I agree.
By Nvyeqa, May 10, 2023 @ 11:06 pm
buy tadalafil 5mg generic order tadalafil 40mg online cheap erectile dysfunction pill
By Doups, May 18, 2023 @ 4:07 am
A $5 wager placed during a progressive poker game at Tropicana Atlantic City last weekend turned into a $1.1 million jackpot for a Monmouth County man. The Deli will be open 24 hours a day, seven days a week for guests of all ages. The Deli’s grill will be open daily from 10AM – 2AM. Seating is provided for up to 36 people and carryout will be available. Smoking is not permitted inside The Deli. For menu details, visit TropEvansville The Borgata also has some very beautiful women walking around serving drinks in the poker room, and the poker room is simply a step above the rest. At any other casino in Atlantic City, you will not see this many beautiful women in one general area. Also, if you like food, there are tons of nice restaurants to dine at as well as a number of fast food stores right down the escalator from the poker room. You can get hamburgers, pizza, cheesesteaks, Chinese food, sushi, salads, ice cream, sandwiches, Mexican food and just about any meals you want when you are staying at The Borgata; they have it all.
http://ahaenuri.org/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=25875
Royal Ace Casino has a customer support team available at all times and every day of the week. Whether you wish to get in touch with a representative directly by a live chat, want to discuss more in details by email or give them a call, all of the methods are available. US and Canadian players have a toll-free number and international players will have a separate phone number they can use. Different departments at Royal Ace Casino have separate email addresses so you can direct your questions from the very beginning. Remember to check the frequently asked questions as well as they might have an answer for you already there. No deposit casino bonuses give players an opportunity to claim free bonus funds from the casino without having to deposit any money into their account. Below, you can read about no deposit bonuses for new players offered by Royal Ace Casino.
By Amhgid, May 20, 2023 @ 11:29 am
accutane 20mg cheap order amoxil 500mg pills zithromax medication
By Xrvbrj, May 22, 2023 @ 3:26 am
order azithromycin 250mg generic oral azithromycin 250mg cost neurontin
By Ijtmqt, May 23, 2023 @ 10:46 pm
buy furosemide without a prescription brand albuterol 2mg order ventolin inhalator online
By Ubritp, May 25, 2023 @ 4:09 pm
levitra online buy buy vardenafil 20mg sale plaquenil 200mg over the counter
By Embrpl, May 25, 2023 @ 5:47 pm
buy altace 10mg sale buy glimepiride 4mg generic etoricoxib 120mg drug
By Fwukyy, June 15, 2023 @ 2:26 pm
purchase ampicillin pills buy ciprofloxacin 500mg pills purchase flagyl pill
By Pbangt, June 15, 2023 @ 2:40 pm
order sumycin 250mg generic order flexeril 15mg online purchase lioresal pills
By Qzormi, June 17, 2023 @ 4:12 am
cost ketorolac generic colchicine inderal pill
By Eveqwc, June 17, 2023 @ 10:20 am
order bactrim generic buy bactrim 960mg generic order cleocin 300mg sale
By Poznsz, June 18, 2023 @ 6:25 pm
plavix pill warfarin 5mg us where can i buy warfarin
By Godgvf, June 19, 2023 @ 6:34 am
generic erythromycin generic tamoxifen 20mg buy tamoxifen 20mg for sale
By Gvgfve, June 20, 2023 @ 9:12 am
reglan 10mg oral metoclopramide 10mg price buy nexium 40mg sale
By Evdiir, June 21, 2023 @ 3:57 am
buy cheap rhinocort ceftin 500mg sale careprost buy online
By Syrzxp, June 22, 2023 @ 1:52 am
buy topamax 100mg without prescription order topamax 200mg sale buy levaquin cheap
By Fcyzxo, June 23, 2023 @ 12:29 am
order methocarbamol 500mg order robaxin 500mg online cheap suhagra 100mg without prescription
By Ohvfbg, June 23, 2023 @ 4:37 pm
buy cheap dutasteride purchase dutasteride online buy meloxicam for sale
By Nolfjq, June 24, 2023 @ 9:15 pm
aurogra where to buy cost aurogra oral estrace 2mg
By Dzcgen, June 25, 2023 @ 6:43 am
buy celebrex pills for sale order tamsulosin order ondansetron 4mg
By Tzgygq, June 26, 2023 @ 9:24 pm
lamotrigine sale purchase prazosin pill order prazosin generic
By Kybfth, June 26, 2023 @ 10:18 pm
spironolactone 25mg drug zocor 10mg without prescription buy valacyclovir 500mg generic
By Mwlspo, June 28, 2023 @ 12:53 pm
finasteride 5mg cheap us viagra sales order sildenafil 100mg pills
By Wzmhil, June 28, 2023 @ 10:46 pm
cheap tretinoin buy tadalafil 10mg generic cost avanafil 200mg
By Tfvruj, July 30, 2023 @ 10:43 am
buy calcitriol 0.25mg pill cheap trandate 100 mg buy tricor 160mg sale
By Ibroku, July 31, 2023 @ 8:39 pm
decadron over the counter nateglinide drug starlix ca
By Uakctn, August 1, 2023 @ 3:47 pm
trileptal 600mg price order ursodiol 150mg generic buy cheap generic urso
By Celena_qhPa, September 2, 2023 @ 10:54 am
Надежный и надежный способ хранения продуктов – стрейч-пленка
стрейч пленка [url=http://moskplenka.ru/]пленка стрейч оптом[/url].
By Ylkxcv, September 2, 2023 @ 11:15 pm
prasugrel 10 mg drug dramamine online order order tolterodine 2mg sale
By Cxcfqd, September 4, 2023 @ 4:05 am
where to buy etodolac without a prescription colospa 135 mg price pletal 100 mg tablet
By Orahel_xyKl, September 5, 2023 @ 3:20 am
Решение для транспортировки продуктов — полипропиленовые мешки
производство мешков полипропиленовых [url=http://tulpak.ru/]производство полипропиленовых мешков в россии заводы[/url].
By Yneeig, September 5, 2023 @ 11:53 pm
ferrous sulfate over the counter order ferrous sulfate 100mg sale cheap sotalol 40mg
By Loaqsy, October 8, 2023 @ 4:59 am
order phenytoin 100 mg pill dilantin online order where can i buy ditropan
By Cvudcv, October 9, 2023 @ 8:21 pm
buy loratadine pills for sale ramipril us dapoxetine 60mg drug
By Fjwapu, October 10, 2023 @ 6:50 am
lioresal cost cheap endep toradol 10mg pills
By Pvlaky, October 11, 2023 @ 11:27 pm
ozobax usa generic ketorolac buy ketorolac sale
By Ncctef, October 12, 2023 @ 6:21 pm
buy cheap generic glimepiride buy etoricoxib online cheap order etoricoxib
By Yndkfv, October 14, 2023 @ 9:45 am
fosamax cheap colchicine cheap buy macrodantin tablets
By Fwftnn, October 16, 2023 @ 3:47 pm
purchase inderal sale buy generic ibuprofen over the counter plavix tablet
By Gjecae, October 18, 2023 @ 8:06 pm
cheap pamelor 25mg order pamelor 25mg anacin online
By Fdvooy, October 20, 2023 @ 7:51 am
where to buy xenical without a prescription order asacol generic buy diltiazem 180mg
By Zayin_qbPa, October 21, 2023 @ 2:55 pm
Удобная противогололедная стрейч-пленка
стрейч пленка купить [url=http://athangelskpak.ru/]стрейч пленка купить цена[/url].
By Rpqovb, October 21, 2023 @ 4:54 pm
cost coumadin 2mg buy generic coumadin online purchase metoclopramide without prescription
By Rczqxr, October 24, 2023 @ 3:04 pm
azelastine where to buy cheap avapro 150mg irbesartan 300mg brand
By Fnrplk, October 25, 2023 @ 4:24 am
pepcid 40mg usa famotidine 20mg price how to get prograf without a prescription
By Igell_moEi, October 27, 2023 @ 4:12 am
Недорогие мешки для строительного мусора для дома
купить мешки под строительный мусор [url=http://lipeckpak.ru/]http://lipeckpak.ru/[/url].
By Prwwud, October 27, 2023 @ 10:10 pm
order nexium 20mg without prescription topiramate 100mg ca topiramate 100mg drug
By Pnssqr, October 28, 2023 @ 9:25 pm
buy zyloprim 300mg sale oral zyloprim 300mg order crestor generic
By Cibjbo, October 29, 2023 @ 11:40 am
buy cheap sumatriptan purchase dutasteride online buy dutasteride paypal
By Ietj_gbEl, October 29, 2023 @ 4:16 pm
Актуальная линейка мешков для мусора
мешков для мусора [url=http://kaluga1pak.ru/]http://kaluga1pak.ru/[/url].
By Windshield Replacement In 27614, April 29, 2024 @ 10:09 pm
The piece was both informative and thought-provoking, like a deep conversation that lingers into the night.
By Top Rated Windshield Replacement 27609, April 29, 2024 @ 10:28 pm
I admire the way you tackled this hard to understand issue. Very enlightening!
By 27523 Auto Glass Shop, April 30, 2024 @ 12:05 am
The insights light up my intellect like fireworks. Thanks for the show!
By Top Rated Windshield Replacement 27560, April 30, 2024 @ 2:20 pm
The research depth is so evident, I almost thought this was a thesis defense.
By auto glass shop near 27410, May 1, 2024 @ 4:17 am
What a refreshing take on this subject. I completely agree with The points!
By auto glass shop in 27263, May 2, 2024 @ 1:09 am
This post is packed with insights, each one a gentle nudge to my intellect and curiosity.
By auto glass shop near 27395, May 2, 2024 @ 10:50 pm
Each article you write is like a step in a dance, moving us gracefully through The thoughts.
By ADAS System for auto glass, May 4, 2024 @ 8:54 pm
The passion is infectious, or maybe that’s just my enthusiasm trying to match Thes. Inspiring, nonetheless!
By windshield repair raleigh, June 3, 2024 @ 12:56 am
ChatGPT
By Wilfredo Derby, June 30, 2024 @ 3:16 pm
https://images.google.co.za/url?q=https://etextpad.com/fqr53wqizd
By Clotilde Rumbach, June 30, 2024 @ 9:27 pm
https://coolpot.stream/story.php?title=clear-vision-ahead-the-ultimate-guide-to-auto-glass-replacement#discuss
By Hyman Grundy, July 1, 2024 @ 11:05 pm
http://quietmona.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=1203789
By Kirk Simonds, July 2, 2024 @ 6:30 am
https://www.google.co.uz/url?q=https://raahauge-yildiz.blogbright.net/shattered-no-more-the-ultimate-guide-to-auto-glass-replacement-1717294248
By Fabian Chargualaf, July 2, 2024 @ 9:16 pm
https://maps.google.ae/url?q=https://jsfiddle.net/potatodraw51/ou158pgb/
By Milo Ruehl, July 3, 2024 @ 9:23 pm
http://bbs.boway.net/home.php?mod=space&uid=906029
By price, July 8, 2024 @ 7:34 am
[url=http://albuterolp.com/]combivent inhaler generic[/url]
By online, July 20, 2024 @ 5:42 pm
[url=https://xlyrica.com/]cheapest price for lyrica[/url]
By pills, August 2, 2024 @ 3:52 pm
[url=https://acyclovirlp.online/]where can i get acyclovir[/url]