The Post Office is Broke

The headline is actually “Post Office Might Miss Retirees’ Payment” but the click-on-me teaser at the WSJ reads Post Office Nears Its First Default. The use of the word “first” not very subtly implies that there will be more. And there will be.

USPS StampIndeed, saying that the USPS “might” miss the $5.5B payment due in ten days is a bit too polite. They do not have the money and Congress has made it clear they will not act before the August recess. And there is a second $5.5B payment due at the end of September.

Which is not to say that missing these payments will cause much in the way of visible effect. They are, essentially, to make up an underfunding in the Postal Service’s pension plan. Skipping them may have serious long-term consequences, but for now the USPS can still buy diesel for its trucks and make payroll. For now.

The Senate did pass a bill rebating $10.9B, a coincidentally convenient figure, to the USPS that it claims to have overpaid into the Federal Employee Pension System. Last fall the GAO found that there was no overpayment, but, hey, this is Washington. The bill also bars closing more post offices, protects Saturday delivery, and declares that Tinkerbelle will live if we all clap our hands. (I may have made up that last bit.) The House has not yet considered it.

There is the argument that the law that requires the Post Office to fully fund its pension and other retirement benefits is unfair.  And it is true that the requirement is fairly unique. Governments, local ones in particular, habitually underfund their pensions, leaving future generations to pick up the bill. And in the private sector pensions are supposed to be funded fully, but the rules are sufficiently arcane and lax that shortfalls large enough to induce bankruptcy can occur. (Anybody else remember GM?)

The USPS has unique pension rules because it is a unique organization, a giant, highly regulated, non-profit company owned by the Federal Government. It has a government granted and enforced monopoly on delivering mail in the US, something that may seem of dubious worth now, but was once nearly a license to print money. And it has always been, at least in intent, self-supporting.

If a state underfunds its pension obligations that is a bad thing, and in as much as it involves politicians borrowing from the future without saying so, often a dishonest thing. But the state will presumably always be there to pay and the taxpayers who get stuck with the bill are the same taxpayers (or their children) who did not pay when the obligations were created.

But it cannot reasonably be argued that the USPS will always be there to pay benefits to retirees. Just when it will cease to exist, next year or 50 years from now, is debatable, but the ultimate result of technology overtaking it is both obvious and inevitable. And when it goes away, it will leave behind hundreds of thousands of retired workers owed pensions and healthcare.

Assuming that we do not intend to just stiff the old letter carriers, the only viable alternative will be that the Federal Government, that is, we taxpayers, will pick up the bill. In other words, saying that the USPS should not have to fully fund its retiree obligations is saying that future taxpayers should subsidize today’s mail service. This seems neither wise nor fair to me.

And the $11B the USPS will not be paying in the next few weeks is in some ways a distracting re-arranging of deck chairs. In the three months ended March 31, the USPS lost $3.2B. (It will not release results for the quarter ended June 30 until August.) Even without the onerous requirement that it pay for the retirement obligations it incurred during the quarter, it still lost $500M.

The brutal truth is that there is not enough money coming in to pay the USPS’s bills on an ongoing basis. And that is not a situation that will get better if left alone. This default is indeed the first of many.


  • By jim, July 20, 2012 @ 6:27 pm

    The USPS pre-funding obligation and the potential (likely) $5.5B default in question is for the USPS future retiree HEALTHCARE benefits, not the pension. Retiree healthcare benefits and pensions are separate funds and regulated differently.

    Unlike pensions, the private retiree healthcare benefits are NOT required to be fully funded.

    For their pensions the USPS employees are covered by the federal pension system (CSRS or FERS). THat obligation is paid and ran as part of the federal pension. In fact the USPS currently has surplus of $13B as of 2011 in the pension side mostly due to their shrinking workforce.

    The USPS certainly needs to fix its financial state for the immediate and long term. But as long as they’re losing money I think its OK to relax the requirement to prefund their retiree healthcare plans just as much as its OK to not require the S&P 500 companies to fund their $500B pension shortfall.

  • By nudge, July 20, 2012 @ 9:16 pm

    And if the advise of the Postmaster General were followed, without input from the Congress, the USPO would be in much better shape. Closing under used facilities and dropping Saturday delivery helps cut expenses. Congress needs to allow the Postmaster General to do his job.

  • By Christine Mattice, July 21, 2012 @ 10:05 am

    This is sad, but I can’t say I’m surprised. With the rise of the Internet, people are simply not using USPS as much, anymore. Plus postage has gotten so expensive!

  • By Craig, July 29, 2012 @ 11:17 am

    Well, I’m no expert–I admit it. But the figure I read is 75 years of benefits–which is to say, a baby was born today who will someday grow up to be a letter carrier, and the USPS is obliged to fund his health care in the year 2087, right now. Am I getting that vaguely right? Because that does seem somewhat onerous. And I also understand that the USPS is fine, operationally–those retiree health care payments are precisely the reason they are underwater today. As I say, I’m not an expert, and I’d be happy to be better informed. But the impression I get is of a mob of Congressmen pinning the USPS to the ground while a couple of them grab its right arm and make it slap itself in the face, all the while saying “Why do you keep hitting yourself?”

  • By Coupon Mage Software, November 3, 2012 @ 6:28 am

    This is sad, but I can’t say I’m surprised :(

  • By Atticus, December 19, 2012 @ 3:56 am

    Man, just when we thought you were back you vanished again!

  • By Mr. West, December 25, 2012 @ 6:36 pm

    “Man, just when we thought you were back you vanished again!”

  • By Mr. West, December 25, 2012 @ 6:39 pm

    Frank probably being investigated by the SEC for something, but hey … giving bad investing advice obviously isn’t a crime!

  • By dieog, January 12, 2013 @ 4:11 pm

  • By Pat Ashley, January 21, 2013 @ 9:37 pm

    The postoffice is still raisng its rates. Maybe if it stopped people wuld use the services more and then they wouldn’t have to default.

  • By Melinda Gonzalez, February 21, 2013 @ 4:32 pm

    I always thought it was odd that the USPS isn’t doing well. Even though people don’t write letters anymore, a HUGE amount of people send packages. Everyone buys stuff online these days, and some are shipped with USPS. I think back in the day there were far less packages delivered by USPS. You would think sending packages would make the USPS more money than stamps. Who knows, maybe it’s just mismanagement. Like everything else government run, perhaps they just don’t know how to budget.

  • By knockoff louis vuitton, March 17, 2013 @ 12:48 am

    WetJet for a month now? It looks like I have! And in the last month my Swiffer has certainly gotten a lot of use. Once a week I use a regular mop and a sink full of hot knockoff louis vuitton

  • By John, March 27, 2013 @ 10:20 pm

    Dude – please write more posts!

  • By Mr. West, May 19, 2013 @ 1:36 pm

    Got it: Frank won the Powerball lottery and went to a Pacific island. His next post: “The Lottery: Play it! Someone is certain to win it.”

  • By Thomas | MADD Finances, May 26, 2013 @ 7:16 pm

    Think they are just bad with money. People are always sending packages out so they cant need letters that much to make money.

  • By askforloans, June 17, 2013 @ 9:30 am

    nice one, i am really influenced by your blog
    for best deal in home loans you may contact to home loan noida

  • By Walton Dodier, August 2, 2013 @ 7:42 am

    Relaxing on the beach with hubby. Home in both cities where my son’s live.

  • By jaket murah, August 6, 2013 @ 8:38 am

    jacket korea
    jual jaket
    toko jaket
    jaket murah

  • By Leslie Thamann, August 6, 2013 @ 6:55 pm

    Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive learn something like this before. So good to find somebody with some original ideas on this subject. realy thanks for beginning this up. this web site is one thing that’s wanted on the web, somebody with slightly originality. helpful job for bringing one thing new to the web!

  • By برامج, August 9, 2013 @ 6:49 pm

    i think they should change to a Shipping company

  • By Mary Devillez, August 10, 2013 @ 3:03 am

    An fascinating discussion is value comment. I feel that you should write more on this matter, it won’t be a taboo subject but usually individuals are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers

  • By Norbert Mazurek, August 14, 2013 @ 3:18 am

    A formidable share, I just given this onto a colleague who was doing just a little analysis on this. And he in reality bought me breakfast as a result of I found it for him.. smile. So let me reword that: Thnx for the treat! But yeah Thnkx for spending the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love reading more on this topic. If attainable, as you turn into expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more details? It is highly helpful for me. Massive thumb up for this blog publish!

  • By Mr. West, August 15, 2013 @ 10:14 pm

    Here’s the book on Frank: Superb writer; smart guy with Ivy League education; asks provocative questions; has big ego; thinks he has all the answers … but the shocking truth: He doesn’t! His wife probably works and he stays home with the kids now.

  • By Robert, August 30, 2013 @ 9:41 am

    good stuff to reading in work

  • By Ali, September 10, 2013 @ 8:56 am

    I’m not surprised

  • By Eden, April 3, 2019 @ 7:36 am

    Consider your average 30-year mortgage. What if you had to set aside a few hundred thousand dollars right now, enough to pay the whole thing, even if you were still going to make payments over 30 years? No one would ever take out a mortgage. That’s the whole point: the costs only come in over time, and the income you use to pay them comes in over time as well. It works exactly the same for retiree pensions and benefit funds. Which is why, as economist Dean Baker pointed out to Congress, pretty much no one else does what the PAEA demanded of the Postal Service.

  • By NgSFKbHUhWx, October 18, 2019 @ 3:56 pm


  • By conttnyjr, November 11, 2019 @ 2:42 am


    Разошлём ваши коммерческие предложения по контактным-формам сайтов фирм России.
    Разошлём ваши сообщения по формам-контактов сайтов организаций по любым странам мира на всех языках.

    Ваше коммерческое предложение приходит на контактный электронный ящик организации.

    десять тысяч сообщений по Российской Федерации на ваш электронный ящик – тысяча руб.
    10000 сообщений по зарубежным зонам на ваш почтовый ящик – 20 $.
    От вас требуется почтовый ящик, заголовок и текст письма.

    Предприятия Российской Федерации – 3012045 организаций – 3500 рублей за миллион.

    Москва и Московская обл. 627545 организаций – 5000 рублей.

    Санкт-Петербург и область 374471 предприятий – 5000 руб.

    Новые организации РФ зарегистрированные в 2016-2018 году – 5000 рублей.

    Новые сайты Российской Федерации, зарегистрированные 24-48 часов назад (Цикл из 15 рассылок в течение месяца). – 15000 руб.

    Україна 605745 доменных имён – 5000 руб.

    Все русскоговорящие страны минус РФ 15 стран 1722657 доменных имён – 10000 руб.

    Вся Europe 44 страны 60726150 сайтов – 60000 руб.

    Весь European Union 28 стран 56752547 сайтов- 55000 руб.

    Вся Азия 48 стран 14662004 доменных имён – 15000 руб.

    Вся Africa 50 стран 1594390 сайтов – 10000 рублей.

    Вся Северная и Центральная America 35 стран 7441637 доменных имён – 15000 руб.

    Вся Южная America 14 стран 5826884 доменных имён – 10000 рублей.

    Новые сайты со всех стран мира зарегистрированные 24-48 часов назад (Цикл из 15 рассылок в течение месяца). – 30000 рублей.

    Рассылки по движкам сайтов:
    Amiro 2294 sites 1000 руб.
    Bitrix 175513 sites 3000 руб.
    Concrete5 49721 sites 2000 руб.
    Контенидо 7769 sites 1000 руб.
    Кубекарт 1562 sites 1000 руб.
    Datalife Engine 29220 sites 2000 руб.
    Дискуз 70252 sites 2000 руб.
    Дотнетнук 31114 sites 2000 руб.
    Друпал 802121 sites 5000 руб.
    Хост CMS 6342 sites 1000 руб.
    Инстант CMS 4936 sites 1000 руб.
    Invision Power Board 510 sites 1000 руб.
    Joomla 1906994 sites 10000 руб.
    Лайфрей 5937 sites 1000 руб.
    Magento 269488 sites 3000 руб.
    Мод икс 67023 sites 2000 руб.
    Movable Type 13523 sites 2000 руб.
    НетКэт 6936 sites 1000 руб.
    НопКомерс 5313 sites 1000 руб.
    OpenCart 321057 sites 3000 руб.
    Open Source Commerce 65468 sites 2000 руб.
    phpBB 3582 sites 1000 руб.
    Prestashop 92949 sites 2000 руб.
    Shopify 365755 sites 3000 руб.
    Симпла 8963 sites 1000 руб.
    Sitefinity 4883 sites 1000 руб.
    Тайпо три 227167 sites 3000 руб.
    ЮМИ ЦМС 15943 sites 2000 руб.
    vBulletin 154677 sites 3000 руб.
    Викс 2305768 sites 10000 руб.
    Вордпресс 14467405 sites 20000 руб.
    Вукомерц 2097367 sites 10000 руб.

    Выборки по сферам деятельности РФ:
    B2B услуги, Cars, Автосервис, Avtotovary, Безопасность, Business, Computers and Internet, Krasota, Культура и искусство, Medicine and Pharmacy, Места и топографические обьекты,Science and education, Образование, Obshchepit, Общество, Отдых и туризм, Produkty, Производство и поставки, Promyshlennye tovary, Razvlecheniya, Реклама и полиграфия, Remont strojka, Family children pets, Спецмагазины, Спорт, Reference Information Systems, Media, Строительство и недвижимость, Телекоммуникации и связь, Tovary dlya doma i dachi, Transport and transportation, Услуги

    Выборки по городам и областям РФ:
    Abakan i Respublika Hakasiya, Anadyr i CHukotskij avtonomnyj okrug, Arkhangelsk and the Arkhangelsk region, Astrakhan and Astrakhan region, Barnaul i Altajskij kraj, Belgorod and Belgorod region, г.Биробиджан и Еврейский автономный округ, Blagoveshensk and Amur region, Bryansk and Bryansk region, Velikij Novgorod i Novgorodskaya oblast, Vladivostok and Primorsky Krai, Vladikavkaz i Respublika Severnaya Osetiya, Vladimir i Vladimirskaya oblast, Volgograd and Volgograd region, Vologda i Vologodskaya oblast, г.Воронеж и Воронежская область, Gorno-Altajsk i Respublika Altaj, г.Грозный и Чеченская Республика, Ekaterinburg i Sverdlovskaya oblast, Ivanovo i Ivanovskaya oblast, Izhevsk and the Republic of Udmurtia, Joshkar-Ola i Respublika Marij EHl, Irkutsk and Irkutsk region, Kazan i Respublika Tatarstan, Kaliningrad and Kaliningrad region, Kaluga i Kaluzhskaya oblast, Kemerovo and Kemerovo region, Kirov and Kirov region, г.Кострома и Костромская область, г.Краснодар и Краснодарский край, г.Красноярск и Красноярский край, Kurgan i Kurganskaya oblast, Kursk i Kurskaya oblast, Kyzyl and Tyva Republic, Lipeck i Lipeckaya oblast, Magadan i Magadanskaya oblast, г.Магас и Республика Ингушетия, г.Майкоп и Республика Адыгея, Makhachkala and the Republic of Dagestan, г.Москва и Московская область, Murmansk and Murmansk region, г.Нальчик и Республика Кабардино-Балкария, Naryan-Mar i Neneckij avtonomnyj okrug, Nizhnij Novgorod i Nizhegorodskaya oblast, г.Новосибирск и Новосибирская область, Omsk i Omskaya oblast, г.Орел и Орловская область, Orenburg and Orenburg region, Penza and Penza region, г.Пермь и Пермский край, г.Петрозаводск и Республика Карелия, г.Петропавловск-Камчатский и Камчатский край, г.Псков и Псковская область, Rostov-on-Don and Rostov Region, г.Рязань и Рязанская область, Salekhard and Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous District, г.Самара и Самарская область, г.Санкт-Петербург и Ленинградская область, Saransk i Respublika Mordoviya, г.Саратов и Саратовская область, Smolensk and Smolensk region, Stavropol i Stavropolskij kraj, Syktyvkar and the Komi Republic, г.Тамбов и Тамбовская область, Tver and Tver region, Tomsk and Tomsk region, Tula and Tula region, Tyumen i Tyumenskaya oblast, Ulan-Udeh i Respublika Buryatiya, г.Ульяновск и Ульяновская область, г.Уфа и Республика Башкортостан, г.Хабаровск и Хабаровский край, Hanty-Mansijsk i Hanty-Mansijskij avtonomnyj okrug, CHeboksary i CHuvashskaya Respublika, г.Челябинск и Челябинская область, Cherkessk and the Republic of Karachay-Cherkessia, CHita i Zabajkalskij kraj, EHlista i Respublika Kalmykiya, г.Южно-Сахалинск и Сахалинская область, Yakutsk and Sakha Republic, Yaroslavl and Yaroslavl region

    Базы для рассылок:
    Организации и Предприятия из сервисов Yandex и Google карт собранные по Общероссийскому классификатору объектов административно-территориального деления: 966 городов, 42187/108072 крупных/мелких населённых пунктов России.
    Организации Российской Федерации из: YP, Дубль Гис, Ros-bis, Актинфо, Алинформ, Бтк-онлайн,Bigphonebook, МБТГ, Gdetomesto, Gdebiz, E-adres, B2B-russia, Заказ РФ, Sam5, Фолиант, Yarmap, Topplan, Tel09, Справочник-09, EGTS, СПР, Interweb.spb, Moscowfirma, ЕГРЮЛ, Data.mos, Мосгид, Msk.spravker и др.
    Базы WHOIS сайтов всех стран мира.
    Вы можете приобрести наши базы отдельно от рассылки по запросу.

    Пожалуйста не отвечайте на это коммерческое предложение со своего почтового ящика, так как оно создано в автоматическом режиме и не дойдёт до нас!
    Используйте для связи контакт-форму рассылка по формам обратной связи

  • By maddy_nUb, August 14, 2020 @ 10:06 pm

    Привет! Пока!

  • By JerryOvasy, September 1, 2020 @ 2:49 pm

    Кто хочет удержать — тот теряет. Кто готов с улыбкой отпустить — того стараются удержать…

    bitcoin mixer |

  • By domtelekomrfub, November 9, 2020 @ 3:17 am


    Интернет в офис, склад, БЦ, частный дом, на дачу, от 280 руб в месяц безлимит абонентская плата . Монтаж оборудования за 3 часа. Подключение от 10.000 руб под ключ в любом месте Москвы Московской области. Монтируем до 150 км от Москвы. Оплата после монтажа. http://www.домтелеком.рф

  • By akruti clinic, February 26, 2021 @ 4:28 am

    Thanks for sharing this information” rel=”nofollow”> akruti conveys its hearty thanks to all the patients for their positive reviews which made us be ranked as Number 1 Center for Cosmetic Surgery in Hyderabad by Times Health Survey. We thank once again for the trust and faith reposed in Akruti. cosmetic surgeon in hyderabad

  • By fifa55bet, April 20, 2021 @ 1:43 am

    ซื้อหวยออนไลน์ senseruay จ่ายจริง อันดับ 1 ใคร ๆ ก็เลือกสมัคร เพราะแทงง่าย มีความมั่นคงทางการเงินสูง น่าเชื่อถือ ไม่โกง 100% เเละ สะดวกที่สุด แถมยังได้อัตราการจ่ายที่สูงถึง บาทละ 900 เลยทีเดียว สำหรับ 3 ตัวบน ส่วน 2 ตัว นั้นให้ บาท ละ 90 นั่นเอง สามารถเลือกแทงหวยได้หลากหลายแบบ

  • By ซื้อหวยออนไลน์, June 21, 2021 @ 5:07 am

    This article presents clear idea in support of the new users of blogging, that in fact how to do blogging.

  • By Anupama hospitals, July 23, 2021 @ 1:38 pm

    In collaboration with the best doctors we also have well-skilled nursing staff, experienced lab professionals, and highly coherent emergency care team. We have consulting suites at the Center for treating minor health ailments. Minimally invasive procedures are offered to make the patients comfortable. The state-of-the-art operation theaters are assets of Apollo Cradle. Our ambulance is ventilator equipped and manned by an EMT ready for any emergency transfers. for more info visit here:-

  • By Verzonzes, October 17, 2021 @ 5:07 pm

    azithromycin dose for children
    zithromax oral suspension
    generic zithromax no prescription
    – can azithromycin alone treat gonorrhea – zithromax 3mg without a doctor prescription
    amoxicillin vs zithromax

  • By ICT Tech, November 6, 2022 @ 11:20 pm

    where do you take topics like this for your website?

Other Links to this Post

  1. DMV online reg — April 29, 2013 @ 10:14 pm

  2. amsoil motorcycle oil near me — January 11, 2019 @ 8:43 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

WordPress Themes