Stocks are not the Only Investment that Counts

Wednesday’s WSJ had a piece on Rethinking Stocks’ Starring Role. It’s about time.

Don’t get me wrong, stocks are an important asset class, maybe even the most important one. But they are just that, a large category of reasonable NYSE things a reasonable person might invest in, but not the only such category. Yet for generations, received wisdom has made it the center of individuals’ investing plans, the main course in the wealth accumulation dinner.

Why? ‘Cuz the stock market went up so darn much over the last fifty years or so. (Er, uh, recent events not included. Let’s say 1957 to 2007.) I know fifty years sounds like a really long time. Long enough that you might consider it to be approximately forever. If the stock market has gone up a certain percentage on average over that long a time a person is sorely tempted to think of that as the basic nature of the beast.

That’s not crazy. Generally, things that are true over fifty years are true forever. But not always. The Red Sox did win the World Series eventually. In the stock market’s case, it’s really not that hard to come up with a story about what happened in the last half-century that made the market go up in a way that is unlikely to be repeated.

In a nutshell, I think it is pretty clear in hindsight that the stock market was way too cheap in the mid 1950′s. I don’t mean cheap based on what we now know would happen in the coming decades, I mean really cheap based on what ought to have been obvious to investors at the time.

It took a long while, several generations in fact, for the market to get to a point where its valuation made sense compared to other asset classes. And it didn’t happen smoothly over the whole period, but in two great phases that changed the way we think about the stock market.

The first was the 1960s and early 1970s, when the accumulated prosperity of the post-war era pushed the market out of the doldrums in which it had been languishing since the 1920s. It was then that thoughtful people started doing research that showed that equities were a good investment as an asset class, something that was, remarkably, not widely understood before the 1960s. And institutional investors (a term newly invented at the time) started soberly putting money in the market. And those institutions had more than ever before to invest, as this was also the period of the rise of the private pension plan.

Then we had the legendary bull run of the 1980s and 1990s, the golden era of the mutual fund and the 401(k), when everybody and their brother decided the stock market was the engine that would propel them into a happy retirement. Until this time, investing in stocks was something associated with the country-club elite. (Although pension managers already commonly did it on behalf of ordinary folks.) By 2000, just about every American with money saved had a reason to check on the daily adventures of the Dow.

The stock market of today is not the same as the market of fifty years ago. It’s role in the economy and in our culture has massively increased. That change brought on a secular rise in the valuation of the market. And that rise is unlikely to be repeated over the next fifty years.

I’m not saying the market won’t go up in the future. On the contrary, I think corporations are pretty good at making money and will stay that way. Owning a piece of the action is bound to be profitable. But part of what made money for stock market investors 1957-2007 was not the growing American economy but a systematic change in what investors were willing to pay for stocks.

Given the risk level of the market, if you assume the 10% or so annual returns we got over the past 50 years, it’s hard not to conclude that stocks should be the centerpiece of your investment plan. But what if, and I think this is not an unreasonable idea, the right expectation from here on out is a lot less? What if it is, for example, 6%?

I’m not going to stick my neck out and say I think that 6% is the right number, but I will say that I think it’s not a crazy one. The 30-year Treasury is yielding 4.1%, so 6% would give a decent margin to compensate for the added risk.

But it would not be such a big margin that you would want to build your investing life around stocks. You’d want some, maybe more of it than other asset classes, but given the risk involved it would not be like stocks were a free lunch you needed to really load up on. And doesn’t that make sense at some level? Oughtn’t the great obvious asset classes return about the same on a risk-adjusted basis?

29 Comments

  • By Mark Wolfinger, September 4, 2009 @ 7:40 pm

    Very compelling argument.

    I’d like to see the results 50 years from now, but will not be able to do that.

  • By abdpbt personal finance, September 5, 2009 @ 10:37 am

    This is a great piece, and really fleshed out the financial picture of the past 50 years for me. But, Frank isn’t it easier to put stuff in mutual funds and blindly accept that the market will go up, without thinking about whether it’s the best choice for your money? Because that’s what I want to do. Now I cannot. So thanks.

  • By fcmm, September 5, 2009 @ 7:17 pm

    Something I don’t hear talked about much regarding the last 50 years of economic trend is the increase of household wealth due to the changes in women’s employment over the time. I think of it more in relation to the housing market – which hasn’t crashed here – people seem to think that because housing has doubled in value every seven years for the last 50 years it will continue to do so. But I think that there has been a fundamental change in economic drivers over that time (more women working and in higher paid jobs) which has contributed significantly to the market. And it seems to me that that trend has to flatten off at some point.

  • By basicmoneytips, September 6, 2009 @ 7:44 am

    I think looking back at the last 50 years verses the next 50 years, the landscape of stock investing has changed and will continue to change.

    By that I mean we live in the information age. 20 years ago you did not have Etrade and yahoo message boards – people followed stocks in their newspapers once a day. Because of this, I think we will see a lot more choppy activity in the stock market (as we have seen since 2000) rather than the long bull runs we saw after the great depression.

    I think diversification is the key – maybe with land, gold, annuities, etc.

  • By Mark Arsenal, September 7, 2009 @ 7:52 am

    I think there is a strong correlation between demographics and asset prices. If you look at the baby boomers age group, you can see that asset prices inflated just at the time that boomers were in their peak earning years, sucking up assets to mop up their excess wealth.

    The crash occurred just as they started dumping assets to liberate that wealth for retirement. Supply-demand alone could explain the entire real estate/stock bubble (and crash) of the past couple decades, perhaps…

  • By Hibryd, September 8, 2009 @ 2:18 am

    So… what would be the alternative? I don’t think I’ll ever have the kind of money (or the necessary knowledge) to individually invest in local companies or buy commodities or do other forms of investing on my own. I probably choose stocks because it’s something I can do incrementally as I have the money to invest, and it’s something I can do over a long period of time. Furthermore, I can sell them off in the same fashion – in whatever amounts at whatever time I need.

    I agree that the stock market is due for a slower couple of decades than it has seen before, but as in individual, where else can I put long-term money?

  • By Samson Smith, September 9, 2009 @ 7:59 am

    Thanks for sharing such great post, it is giving good information about stock investment.

  • By Doug Stalnaker, September 23, 2009 @ 2:40 pm

    I agree with By Hybrid, this post begs for a follow-up. What *is* the alternative??

  • By FC, January 30, 2013 @ 2:44 am

    Great post. Between 1950 and now stocks became mainstream and that pumped them up. It was a big structural change that is not likely to happen again. Could there be some other type of large structural change that could propel stocks higher or lower in the next few decades?

    Or is there some profound structural change occurring now that will create big returns in some other investment or asset class in the next ten to twenty years?

  • By Doups, May 17, 2023 @ 10:00 pm

    After going through the registration process, all new customers will receive a “no deposit required” bonus of $25 as a gift from PartyPoker. The $25 bonus will be allocated as follows: The current PartyPoker Welcome offer was introduced by management on January 1, 2023, with the intention that the offer will continue until the end of the year on December 31, 2023. To claim this bonus, new customers will need to complete the PartyPoker registration process and make a subsequent real cash deposit. For players who enjoy casino games or sports betting, the partypoker network in the US provides various options across its sites. Its online casinos offer traditional table games such as roulette and blackjack, and a recent innovation has seen the introduction of live dealer tables, where players can interact with real-life croupiers.
    https://weddingknn.com/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=113087
    Latest poker news, poker strategies and special offers. Of course, poker chips are often different colors -because the chip value does not correlate to a reimbursable cash amount. Buy 3 Get 1 Free Mix & Match Latest poker news, poker strategies and special offers. Qualify multiple times to earn bonus starting chips for playoff events and even the national final! Stack em up! ALSO – bring a friend to any regular season tourney and they will receive bonus chips, and so will you! The Lodge Card Club 22mm in diameter * 2mm thick Be the first to know about our new arrivals, exclusive offers and giveaways. Sign up now to be emailed our $10 voucher* Minimum deposit of $100 is required to claim the welcome bonus. Use BetUS promo code ‘JOIN125′ to claim. You must bet on odds of 2.8:1 or higher. The offer is subject to a 14-day time limit. Max cash out limits apply.

  • By Expocky, October 11, 2023 @ 4:19 pm

    Table 7 includes commonly occurring drug interactions affected by phenytoin the active metabolite of fosphenytoin sodium injection daily cialis online

  • By Dom, June 10, 2024 @ 2:21 am

    Enjoy free 1xbet games. With an account, you can access free games. These titles are available in the casino section and allow players to try out the quality of the titles before wagering real money. The Live Casino section of 1xBet features games with real croupiers. There is a collection of live dealer games from more than 50 studios, including industry leaders Ezugi, Pragmatic Play, and Evolution Gaming. The entertainment is sorted into popular, keno, blackjack, others, roulette, new, baccarat, jackpot, poker. There’s a huge number of casino games available on the 1xbet app. Some of the more thrilling ones are poker, baccarat, blackjack, slots, jackpot games, Hindi-style live dealer games, etc. 1xBet app is a convenient platform for betting via smartphone on Android or iOS in Hindi, English, and Bengali. The minimum deposit amount is INR 100. You can use UPI, PayTM, and other popular payment systems in India to deposit. Users from India can legally download the 1xBet app and get a welcome bonus of 120% up to 42,900 INR on their first deposit.
    http://withealth.co.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=106041
    рџЋѕ bet365 excels at event coverage and market variety, while also offering live streaming of certain matches, in-play betting, a whole tonne of tennis related promotions, not to mention bet builder options and cash out. But what really singles out Bet365, plus a couple of more, against other tennis betting sites, is their retirement guarantee. You back a player who retires mid-match, you’ll get your stake back. See the full analysis of top tennis betting sites here. A number of the top sportsbook apps, such as BetMGM and DraftKings, will let you create your account via their mobile app or desktop site, giving you the choice as to how you go about creating your account.  Whether you’re making a moneyline bet or making player prop bets, these top US mobile sportsbook apps are perfect for sports bettors. The sportsbook reviews on these apps are top-notch, as you can see in the table below with fantastic user scores.

  • By Michaelnep, July 10, 2024 @ 8:46 pm

    mexican drugstore online
    https://cmqpharma.com/# mexican rx online
    purple pharmacy mexico price list

  • By HenryWaste, July 11, 2024 @ 1:22 am

    mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: cmqpharma.com – medication from mexico pharmacy

  • By Joync, July 12, 2024 @ 4:47 pm

    RTG delivers an exceptional experience with the most innovative game solutions and multi-channel software, you’ll be delighted to know that you can now claim your Casino No Deposit Bonus and start playing your favorite games for free. Well let you know if there are any tournaments to take part in, we’ll take a closer look at online pokies free no deposit bonus offers. We ended up rejecting the complaint because the player refused to use an alternative withdrawal method to cash out his winnings since there are currently no other options, you can always join a site without taking a bonus. With the increasing popularity of online gaming, then you should simply move on to another site. You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked. Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page.
    https://ajax-directory.com/listings275049/the-best-poker-player
    If you prefer to keep the online slot experience as close to the traditional slot machine as possible, the 3-reel games are your best bet. With one to three paylines, these slots are easy to follow. And just because these variants don’t have the elaborate themes of their 5-reel counterparts, doesn’t mean they don’t have themes at all. Here are a few of the themes you’ll find in the 3-reel section of our slots casino as well as an example of a game that encompasses the theme: What you don’t know about Hard Rock for real money casino games but should: Hard Rock’s main menu has a list of “Atlantic City” games with online versions of dozens of slots you’ll find on the casino floor at Hard Rock Atlantic City. It’s the next best thing to being there. To play slot games for real money and win cash at SlotoCash, you need to start with a deposit. The minimum deposit is just $5, making it easy to get started. We offer a wide range of betting options to suit every budget. Many games start at just a few cents per play, with the ability to adjust your bet up to hundreds of dollars for higher stakes action. The cost of playing online slots for real money varies based on your bankroll and how much you choose to bet per spin.

  • By brory, July 15, 2024 @ 5:19 am

    Moreover, Swiatek is favored against the field to win the tournament. At FanDuel, she has odds of -180 to prevail in Paris. Swiatek is the only player in the futures market with odds below +500. Circa Sports Colorado encourages you to gamble responsibly on its mobile app. Gambling problem? Call or TEXT 1-800-GAMBLER or visit problemgamblingcoalitioncolorado.org. Here’s a look at how World Series odds stack up across MLB. We’ll be updating throughout the season to show how the odds race evolves. Don Best What’s not to like about the Yankees at +600? The Bronx Bombers sit atop the majors in home runs with 83, led by MVP front-runner Aaron Judge and his MLB-leading 22 homers, .677 slugging percentage, and 1.059 OPS (Judge also leads the AL with 46 runs, and his .315 batting average ranks eighth). The Yanks can win on the mound, too, though. They hold the MLB lead in ERA (2.74), WHIP (1.04), and OBA (.210), and they’ve allowed six fewer homers than any other club (38). They were the first squad to reach 40 wins this season (40-15), and they’re 23-7 at home. If injuries don’t rear their ugly head like they always seem to for Aaron Boone’s squad, we could easily see pinstriped players hoisting the Commissioner’s Trophy this fall.
    https://www.saprec.org/forum/welcome-to-the-forum/create-post
    For example, if a bet is placed on HT FT Win-Draw (WD) then the same team must be winning at half time and then the match must be drawn at full time. All football predictions on OneMillionPredictions are completely free. All football predictions on OneMillionPredictions are completely free. Copyright © 2024 Bet The Builder | A Half Time Full Time bet is usually not aimed at predicting an exact score. There is no need to forecast whether Team A will lead at half time with a score of 2:1, but ends up losing the game to Team B with a final score of 2:3. This bet lands if Man City, Arsenal and Liverpool score six or more first-half goals between them this weekend against teams they are 1 12, 1 5 and 1 5 to win this weekend. 15:00 EIF – IF Gnistan X217:00 Gambia – Seychelles Under 2.5 HT18:00 PKKU – Atlantis X2

  • By DavidTAb, July 19, 2024 @ 10:59 pm

    reputable canadian pharmacy: online canadian drugstore – canadian pharmacy world reviews

  • By Charlesaduro, July 19, 2024 @ 11:26 pm

    legit canadian pharmacy online canada pharmacy 24h canadian pharmacy online ship to usa

  • By DavidTAb, July 20, 2024 @ 4:10 am

    buying from online mexican pharmacy: mexico drug stores pharmacies – medicine in mexico pharmacies

  • By MichaelCib, July 20, 2024 @ 4:43 am

    medication canadian pharmacy: canada pharmacy world – online canadian pharmacy review

  • By MerlinMot, July 20, 2024 @ 5:43 am

    purple pharmacy mexico price list: reputable mexican pharmacies online – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs
    https://indiapharmast.com/# top 10 pharmacies in india
    onlinecanadianpharmacy 24 canadian pharmacy cheap trustworthy canadian pharmacy

  • By Edwardheene, July 20, 2024 @ 6:09 am

    https://foruspharma.com/# mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  • By Charlesaduro, July 20, 2024 @ 6:47 am

    canadian mail order pharmacy certified canadian international pharmacy canadian pharmacy antibiotics

  • By DavidTAb, July 20, 2024 @ 9:02 am

    ed drugs online from canada: the canadian drugstore – canadian pharmacy ratings

  • By MichaelCib, July 20, 2024 @ 2:17 pm

    п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india: reputable indian pharmacies – reputable indian online pharmacy

  • By DavidTAb, July 20, 2024 @ 2:38 pm

    top online pharmacy india: indian pharmacy paypal – india online pharmacy

  • By Charlesaduro, July 20, 2024 @ 4:47 pm

    medicine in mexico pharmacies mexican drugstore online mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  • By Edwardheene, July 20, 2024 @ 6:38 pm

    https://indiapharmast.com/# Online medicine order

  • By DavidTAb, July 20, 2024 @ 7:48 pm

    canadian pharmacy prices: safe canadian pharmacy – cheap canadian pharmacy online

Other Links to this Post

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment

WordPress Themes